Charity begins at home for SA batters

“That’s the nature of the beast.” – Faf du Plessis on Beuran Hendricks’ nightmare over that went for 28 runs and, along with too many limp dismissals, cost South Africa victory in the first T20I.

TELFORD VICE | Newlands

A framed black-and-white photograph hangs among eight others on a wall of the press’ temporary situation at Newlands. It is of Jacques Kallis on the hook. All that touches the ground, a good 15 centimetres behind the crease, is the toe-end of his right boot. His left leg is almost straight out in front of him, kicking the air can-can style, the toe-end of that boot at his eye level.

His head has swivelled to face backward square leg. His hands have whipped through the shot and are about to reach the equator drawn from the point of his left shoulder. The look in his eyes is of a gnarled boxer who has landed the left hook of his life. Mercifully, the ball has fled the scene.

Only then does it hit you: he’s in whites! Kallis has played this outrageous stroke, this thing of visceral, lasting power, this immaculate confection of ambition and impossibility … in a Test match!

Even in its static, two-dimensional form the photograph is a sight much richer and rewarding than what was going on out the window in lurid full colour. South Africa were playing their first match in 265 days at Newlands on Friday: a T20I against England, which will be followed by two more and then three ODIs.

The total in attendance, players, umpires, scorers and all, was 306. And six Egyptian geese, who made determined but foiled attempts to cross the pitch while South Africa were putting up 179/6, the fourth-highest first innings in the 20 T20Is played here and the home side’s second-biggest at this ground.

It was also 25 runs more than South Africa scored when they beat England in September 2007 — the only one of the three day/night T20Is played at this ground won by the side batting first.

But that was when T20 cricket was as new as Test cricket seems old now. So the target should have been significantly bigger. Of the South Africans dismissed, only format debutant George Linde, who was yorked with the last ball of the innings, wasn’t charitable with his wicket.

Worse, Quinton de Kock gave his away with a blip to cover to end a steady march to 30, Faf du Plessis looked like he had been batting for weeks — which he has — before holing out to square leg for 58, and Rassie van der Dussen had forged flintily to 37 when he slapped a full toss to deep backward square. South Africa’s batting reeked of the cricketing criminality of unfinished business.      

The geese stalked the outfield throughout England’s reply, seemingly unalarmed when Jason Roy left the field in a flurry of F-words after trying to sweep the second ball of the innings — bowled by Linde — and edging to De Kock, and didn’t flinch when Jos Buttler and Dawid Malan also got out inside the first six overs. Neither did Ben Stokes’ picking out Linde on the long-on fence in the 15th, after clipping 37 off 27, to end a stand of 85 with Jonny Bairstow, ruffle their feathers.

Maybe they knew Bairstow was up for the fight. His combative 86 not out, a performance worthy of a fiery, bearded redhead, kept England on top throughout an innings that wobbled this way and that. Bairstow faced 48 balls and hit 60 of his runs in fours and sixes. And he hit them properly, none more so than the one-handed drive he sent scurrying through the coves for four despite Beuran Hendricks’ low full toss swinging away late.

Perhaps the geese also knew that, with neither of allrounders Andile Phehlukwayo and Dwaine Pretorius in the XI, Heinrich Klaasen would be called on to bowl for the first time in his 12 T20Is, that he would bowl to Stokes and Bairstow, and that his single over would cost 14 runs.

And that Hendricks would lose the plot in a nightmarish 17th over that started with England needing 51. When it ended, they needed 23. Two singles, three fours and a six was bad enough, but what melted South Africa’s hopes was the eight wides — five of them off one delivery that hit the ground for the first time somewhere in the outfield on its way to the fine leg fence. The geese, along with every South Africa supporter, knew from the start it was a dumb idea to leave out Anrich Nortjé.  

If Hendricks needs a shoulder to cry on, he has Du Plessis’, who said: “In T20 cricket you’re guaranteed that someone is going to go on the night. As a leader, I wouldn’t look into it too much if one guy goes for runs. That’s the nature of the beast. Tomorrow he could bowl in the exact same areas and he gets a five-for. I wouldn’t judge him too harshly. Tonight wasn’t his night, and they played well against him.”

Bairstow clinched England’s five-wicket win with four balls to spare: a six arched towards the building site beyond long-on. It was a handsome stroke without being special, a way to get the job done rather than a blow that will be frozen in a frame to arrest all who see it. Kallis would approve, but not be impressed.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Has Shamsi turned into a Test spinner?

8/32 the best figures by a slow bowler in South Africa in 25 years.

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

IT’S too soon to say Tabraiz Shamsi should replace Keshav Maharaj in South Africa’s Test team, but the left-arm wrist spinner did his cause no harm at St George’s Park this week.

Shamsi, who has played 44 white-ball internationals but only two Tests, took 8/32 for the Titans in the second innings of their match against the Warriors. Maharaj, South Africa’s first-choice Test spinner since 2016, claimed match figures of 3/187 for the Dolphins against the Knights in Bloemfontein.

Both matches were played on slow surfaces that took turn, but neither will be used in the Test series against Sri Lanka — which will be played at Centurion and the Wanderers from December 26. Those are the fastest pitches in the country, and spin is likely to be little more than an afterthought.

So Beuran Hendricks’ career-best 7/29 in the first innings for the Lions against the Cobras in Johannesburg, and the 3/56 he took in the second dig to complete match figures of 10/85, could be his ticket to more Test caps. 

Shamsi’s haul bettered Dale Steyn’s 8/41 against the Eagles — the Knights former name — in Bloem in December 2007 as the best performance by any bowler in an innings for the Titans. Not since Stephen Peall took 9/76 for a Zimbabwe Board XI against Boland B in Paarl in October 1995 has a spinner returned better innings figures in a first-class match South Africa.

Unsurprisingly, Shamsi stood out in a match in which no-one made a century — Dean Elgar scored 66 and Heinrich Klaasen 68 among four half-centuries — and no other bowler took more than four wickets in an innings. The Warriors were dismissed for 124 in their second innings and the Titans knocked off their target of 63 in nine overs to win by eight wickets.

Back in Bloem, Raynard van Tonder’s 166 took the Knights to a first innings total of 424. Migael Pretorius, who made his career-best score of 62 in that innings, and Alfred Mothoa shared seven wickets to dismiss the Dolphins for 162, and a century stand for the Knights between Pite von Biljon and Farhaan Behardien, who scored 93 and 50, set the visitors a target of 471. They were bowled out for 243 with Pretorius taking 4/52 to complete a match haul of 7/102.

With Hendricks on fire at the Wanderers, the Cobras were shot out for 115, of which Kyle Verreyne scored 55 off 66 balls. Opener Dominic Hendricks was ninth out for 130 in the Lions’ reply of 324, a difference of 209 runs. The Cobras crashed to 22/3 in their second innings before Tony de Zorzi and Verreyne steadied them with a partnership of 136 and scores of 67 and 72. But they were both dismissed before George Linde took guard at 167/5 to score an unbeaten 69. That, and Nandré Burger’s 38 not out, helped the Cobras take the lead and stay at the crease until elbows were bumped on the draw.

Thursday’s results mean the Titans and the Knights have won both their fixtures while the Dolphins have slipped to their first loss. The Warriors have gone down twice, and the Cobras have lost and drawn.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Plenty to ponder as runs, wickets, results flow

Dean Elgar and Keshav Maharaj bank the best performances among the Test captain candidates.

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

POSITIVE results all round, two big centuries, three other mere hundreds, a triple-century stand, two-five wickets hauls, and an intriguing sub-plot starring the contenders for the Test captaincy. South Africans hoping the season’s opening round of first-class fixtures would be eventful enough to take their minds off the wider state of cricket in their country couldn’t have asked for more.

All three matches reached the fourth day on Thursday, with the Knights becoming the first team to wrap up victory, by 179 runs, over the Warriors in Bloemfontein. At Kingsmead the Dolphins were nine-wicket winners over the Lions. The Titans nipped home by two wickets against the Cobras at Newlands.

Sarel Erwee scored 199 and Keegan Petersen 173 in the Dolphins’ first innings. They put on 337 for the second wicket after the first fell to the third ball of the innings. Keshav Maharaj shared the new ball in the Lions’ second innings and took 6/101.

Gerrit Snyman’s 78-ball 109 was the standout feature of the game in Bloem. It marked the first time a player had reached a century before lunch on the opening day in a domestic first-class match in South Africa since 1978.

Only four completed totals in first-class cricket history worldwide to include a century have been lower than the Titans’ first innings effort of 150. The centurion was Dean Elgar, who made 101. George Linde claimed 5/65 to help the Cobras take a lead of 114 into the second innings. Tabraiz Shamsi’s 4/79 and tight bowling by all — part-timer Aiden Markram’s seven overs cost only 10 runs — kept the Titans’ target to 316, which they passed after lunch with Theunis de Bruyn seventh out for 127. Elgar scored 58 and Linde’s 4/123 gave him match figures of 9/188.

At least until the second round starts on Monday, Linde, Shamsi and Maharaj — spinners all and all left-armers, though a mix of orthodox and un — are the top wicket-takers in a country where fast bowlers rule.  

The needle match of the round was at Newlands, not least because the visitors’ coach, Mandla Mashimbyi, had joked that the Cobras amounted to a “Titans B team”. Four members of the home side’s XI were previously attached to the Titans or their feeder province, Northerns. The result means the Cobras, the only team not to win a match in this competition last season, have gone 10 first-class games without victory.

Elgar and Maharaj have both declared their ambition to succeed Faf du Plessis as Test captain. Another candidate, Markram, made up for treading on his wicket in the first innings — when he scored two — with an assured 48 in the second dig. Temba Bavuma, who is also in the leadership mix, scored 43 and 25 for the Lions. Still another, Rassie van der Dussen, made one and 10, also for the Lions.

Elgar restated his case for the captaincy with characteristic forthrightness in an exclusive interview this week with Cricket Fanatics, a Cape Town-based online magazine: “Without sounding arrogant or pig-headed, I think it would make the one logic sense [sic] in Cricket South Africa at the moment. In saying that, that’s out of your control as a player. I do feel it’s a position I’ve really tried to groom myself for, from a personal point of view. But it’s totally out of my powers. There are other people who make those decisions, and rightly so. You’ve got to respect whichever way they want to go.”

One of those people is Victor Mpitsang, the new convenor of selectors, who ended his career with the Knights as Elgar’s was starting: they were in the same XI for the franchise in four first-class matches in 2010-11. The other party in picking the new captain is Graeme Smith, the director of cricket, who opened the batting with Elgar in both innings of one of the nine Tests they played together.

Sharing a dressingroom with the famously feisty Elgar can be challenging — little stops him from speaking his mind. But by all accounts he, Mpitsang and Smith have remained on good terms. None of the other captaincy hopefuls have direct ties to the people who matter in this process.

Advantage Elgar? We will know in the coming weeks: the Test series against Sri Lanka starts on December 26.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

MSL catches fire in PE

As a window into what the MSL could be if major players in the sponsorship and broadcast world were able to have confidence that it was a good place to spend their money, it was bittersweet.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

THE Mzansi Super League (MSL) took the edge off its problems by delivering the closest game yet in this year’s competition at St George’s Park on Wednesday.

Plagued by inadequate sponsorship and broadcast revenue, ineffective marketing, little prospect of breaking even, and tiny crowds, the MSL doesn’t have much going for it.

But, for three or so hours while the Nelson Mandela Bay Giants and the Cape Town Blitz conjured a contest for the ages, none of that mattered as acutely.

The Blitz put up a decent 186/9 — the Warriors’ 189 against the Cobras in April is the only higher T20 first innings at this ground, and remains the record total — and the Giants reeled it in with five wickets standing and four balls to spare.

Janneman Malan and Quinton de Kock shared 72 for the first wicket for the second time in the tournament in scoring 31 and 39, and the rest of the visitors’ top five — Marques Ackerman, Liam Livingstone and Asif Ali — added another 87 to the total.

But the Giants fought back, taking 5/22 to limit the damage effectively.

Chris Morris, Junior Dala, Imran Tahir and Onke Nyaku claimed two wickets each with Tahir’s 2/26 and economy rate of 6.50 the standout showing.

The Giants seemed sunk without trace after only nine balls, what with openers Matthew Breetzke and Jason Roy gone with just three runs scored.

But captain Jon-Jon Smuts stood tall through partnerships of 53 with Ben Dunk, 46 with Heino Kuhn and 48 with Marco Marais before slashing a catch to backward point to go for a 51-ball 73.

Smuts’ gutsy effort included a reprieve for a no-ball dismissal by Wahab Riaz and surviving a lengthy review for a catch by George Linde at short fine leg off Sisanda Magala.

His exit, forced by a near no-ball from Wahab, left Marais — the cleanest, crispest, hardest hitter in South African cricket since Rassie van der Dussen — and Morris to get the job done, which they did by clattering 37 off 18 balls.

Morris clinched it in soap opera style with a mighty heave off Magala, which Linde, diving for all his worth on the midwicket fence, almost caught.

Instead the ball was deflected onto the boundary cushion, which cost the Blitz six runs, the match, and their position at the top of the standings — a spot now occupied by the Giants.

As a game of cricket it was the stuff of dreams: dramatic and intensely competitive with a fair sprinkling of quality individual performances.

As a window into what the tournament could be if major players in the sponsorship and broadcast world were able to have confidence that the MSL was a good place to spend their money, it was bittersweet.

Reality resumed, and with it an interview Hashim Amla gave to Pakistani website PakPassion.

“I find it very amusing whenever this whole subject of Kolpak and its effects on South African cricket are brought up,” Amla was quoted as saying.

“Kolpak has been around for a long time, and so it’s surprising to me that it is been touted as the reason for all evils only because we lost the recent Test series to India [3-0 in October].

“I do not want this idea to become a convenient excuse for what basically were bad performances against India.

“When I was playing domestic cricket, we had quite a number of Kolpak players in our domestic teams also but then there was no talk of this subject.

“Let’s be honest about it, India are a really good side and they will probably beat all teams at home and the fact is that we did not play that well during the tour.

“Now one may argue that I am saying this because I have signed to play for Surrey next year as a Kolpak player but my story is slightly different as I have a few years of international cricket under my belt.

“The fact remains that this whole issue has gained importance just due to recent bad performances.”

Amla spoke from the United Arab Emirates, where he is playing for the Karnataka Tuskers in the Abu Dhabi T10 — a fact that on its own is indicative of some of South African cricket’s problems beyond Kolpak.

Having served as the Blitz’ batting consultant, free of charge, Amla has done his bit for the MSL.

But, if the game was in better shape at home, wouldn’t he prefer playing in the MSL to some gimmick far away?

You didn’t need to be at St George’s Park on Wednesday to answer that question.

First published by TMG Digital.

How will SA pick their squad to play England?

A hattrick of headaches: No positives from the India series, no help from first-class cricket, and no selectors.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

IT’S no surprise that none of the players who were in South Africa’s men’s Test squad in India last month are among the leading runscorers in the franchise first-class competition.

The internationals were in the subcontinent for the first three rounds of the four-dayers, and most of them did not play in the fourth round.

So the top Test batter in domestic terms this season is Heinrich Klaasen, who is 44th on the list of runscorers.

The leading bowler, on the same score, is George Linde, who is sixth among the wicket-takers.

Not that the national selectors take their cues from first-class cricket. South Africa’s internationals don’t play nearly enough at that level to make this a factor in picking a Test squad.  

But the India series was a catastrophe of historic proportions — not since 1935 have South Africa lost consecutive Tests by an innings — and only one more round of four-day cricket is scheduled before the series against England starts on December 26.

So the selectors have little to go on for a plan to halt the slide.

Ah. About that: there are no selectors. The panel was disbanded in the wake of South Africa’s World Cup meltdown.

That means the relevant suit at Cricket South Africa (CSA) will have their work cut out choosing a squad that could turn things around.

Right. Except that, until late last month, the relevant suit was interim director of cricket Corrie van Zyl — who has been suspended.

Might Enoch Nkwe do the needful, considering he was South Africa’s interim team director in India, with Faf du Plessis?

Problem: Nkwe was appointed for that tour only, and as yet there has been no clarity on whether he will be replaced or continue in the role. 

Might the job of assembling the squad to play one of the most important series in South Africa’s history fall to CSA chief executive Thabang Moroe?

Asked who might select the squad, a CSA spokesperson said: “CSA has capably qualified personnel to handle all tasks related to the selection of all our squads.

“We are comfortable that this will be handled in line with international cricket best practices.

“The chief executive officer does not select the squad.”

But we still don’t know who does. What we do know is that until December 19 — when the Cobras and Knights clash in Paarl, the Dolphins play the Warriors at Kingsmead, and the Lions and the Titans have a go at the Wanderers — cricketminded South Africans will have to glean what they can about the state of the game on the field from the Mzansi Super League (MSL).

That’s a hopelessly imperfect exercise given the differences in format and standard, but it can’t hurt that Temba Bavuma, Quinton de Kock and Dean Elgar are among the top 10 runscorers.

Neither that Anrich Nortjé and Kagiso Rabada are two of the leading 10 wicket-takers, with Linde 12th in the batting charts and joint fifth among the bowlers.

But it is less than edifying that Du Plessis, Keshav Maharaj, Lungi Ngidi, and Vernon Philander are all outside the top 20 in their respective disciplines.

Then again, Du Plessis has had only two innings while Maharaj and Philander have bowled just four overs and Ngidi a mere three.

“If you look at the MSL, a lot of guys are coming through and they’re playing really well,” Dale Steyn of the Cape Town Blitz told reporters at Kingsmead on Sunday after the match against the Durban Heat.

“Today’s a prime example of a young man I’ve never heard of stepping up and nearly scoring a hundred.”

Steyn was talking about Wihan Lubbe, who hit 15 of his 42-ball 83 off the six deliveries he faced from the Test stalwart — who had the satisfaction of dismissing him.

But Lubbe is probably not among the answers to the questions South Africa face heading into the England series.

There are often more questions than answers when a squad needs to be chosen.

Thing is, this time, who is going to ask them, nevermind answer them?

First published by TMG Digital.

CSA miss own deadline on Cobras transformation issue

“I can’t comment on what goes on right at the top but I can certainly say there’s great talent in South Africa.” – Robin Peterson focuses on the positive.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

CRICKET South Africa (CSA) seem set to miss their self-imposed deadline for getting to the bottom of a transformation target transgression last month.

The Cobras’ XI for their first-class fixture against the Warriors at Newlands included seven black players — one more than the stipulated number.

But only two of them, fast bowlers Thando Ntini and Tladi Bokako, were black African — one fewer than the target.

“CSA has noted the submission by Western Cape Cricket [WCC] in lieu of a request for a deviation from the administrative conditions,” a CSA spokesperson said at the time.

But, according to Cobras coach Ashwell Prince, there was nothing “in lieu” about how he had approached the issue.

“I followed the protocol,” Prince told TMG Digital.

CSA also said they would “launch a further enquiry into this incident and will consider all the related and relevant information in order to arrive at a decision about the strength and the validity of the argument by WCC”, and that, “It is anticipated that the investigation may take up to 14 days.”

That was on October 29 — the 14 days expires on Tuesday.

Asked on Monday night whether CSA had reached a decision, a spokesperson said only, “We will announce the outcome once we have concluded the matter.”

Pressed for a better answer, he became defensive.

The Cobras squad contains four other black Africans — batters Aviwe Mgijima and Simon Khomari, and fast bowlers Akhona Mnyaka and Mthiwekhaya Nabe — while another, spinner Tsepo Ndwandwa, has played for them this season.

None were injured when the game against the Cobras started at Newlands on October 28.

Mgijima has scored just 39 runs in five first-class innings this season while Khomari made two and four in his only match of the campaign.

Mnyaka took 1/30 in the nine overs he bowled on his debut in January, his only first-class match to date.

Nabe also last played for the Cobras in January, and has taken 47 wickets in 31 first-class games at an average of 43.27.

Ndwandwa has claimed three wickets in the two first-class games he has played for the Cobras this season.

In cricket terms, none of those players are banging down the door for a place in the Cobras team.

Who might have been left out to make room for another black African is another consideration.

Five members of the top six who played average more than 30 this summer, with Kyle Verreynne topping the list at 70.66 and Matthew Kleinveldt weighing in at 56.00.

The only merely black — not black African — fast bowler in the side, Dane Paterson, has taken 18 wickets at 21.55 in four games.

The other three members of the team, Zubayr Hamza, George Linde and Dane Piedt, the captain, were all freshly back from South Africa’s poor Test series in India.

It was thus in the national interest that they played. 

And in the Cobras’ interest: before that match they had lost to the Lions and drawn with the Titans and Dolphins.

The game against the Warriors was also drawn, leaving the Cobras second from bottom in the standings.

There was, therefore, no good cricket case to be made for forcing an out-of-form player into a side that needed a win at the expense of someone better equipped for their role.

But, as the Springboks proved emphatically at the men’s World Cup in Japan, quotas can lead to triumph because they open eyes that were previously closed.

There’s a good argument to be made that the Boks would not have done as well as they did had teams not been forced to pick black players.

Decades of selection bias — consciously or not — robbed black players of their opportunities.

With their presence guaranteed, they could not be unfairly sidelined.

And, what do you know, they turned out to be among the best players South Africa had.

That Siya Kolisi, Makazole Mapimpi and Cheslin Kolbe merit their places is beyond question.

As is the likelihood that, without quotas, they would never have been given the chance to prove it.  

It’s a happy ending cricket is still chasing, and the dwindling confidence in CSA’s current leadership won’t bring it any closer. 

Perhaps that vital task should be left to people who know what they’ve doing, like Warriors coach Robin Peterson.

“I can’t comment on what goes on right at the top but I can certainly say there’s great talent in South Africa,” Peterson told TMG Digital during the now controversial Newlands match.

He is about 18 months from completing a Masters in sport directorship at Manchester Metropolitan University.

Peterson hasn’t yet decided what his dissertation topic will be, but he has an idea.

“Maybe I’ll do it on ethical transformation,” he said. “Is there such a thing as ethical transformation?

“I’m living in a situation I can write about, so why not.”

Given South Africa’s past and present, Peterson won’t want for research material.

“It’s very difficult to heal wounds, but if this is your only skill in life it’s very difficult to kill people’s dreams.

“You have to give them opportunities if they’re good enough to play.”

It seems a simple statement, but South Africans will know just how complex it is.

First published by TMG Digital. 

SA cricket fiddling with MSL while Test team burns

“I’m sure there are people in much higher positions than myself, at Proteas level and CSA level, who know exactly how they are going to go about improving the situation.” – Ashwell Prince keeps the faith.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

WITH South Africa’s men’s Test team at their lowest point and a series against England starting in just more than seven weeks, the responsible approach would be to divert all efforts into putting out the fire.

Instead, South Africa’s players will fiddle with the Mzansi Super League (MSL) for more than five weeks of that precious time.

Ashwell Prince, who placed a higher price on his wicket than most, and who consequently must have been more frustrated than most at South Africa’s flaccid batting in India last month, might have been able to help fix the problem if his Cobras were out there every week playing first-class cricket.

But that opportunity will be wasted because Prince will coach the Cape Town Blitz in the MSL, which starts on Friday.

“I don’t want to make comments about the Proteas and Test cricket at the moment,” Prince told a press conference in Cape Town on Monday. “I think we’re all here for the exciting second edition of the MSL.

“I’m sure there are people in much higher positions than myself, at Proteas level and CSA [Cricket South Africa] level, who know exactly how they are going to go about improving the situation.

“But at the moment I want to focus on the Blitz. We’ve got an exciting team with some exciting players, and we want to go out and enjoy that, and entertain.”

Except that figures who “know exactly how they are going to go about improving the situation” are thin on the ground.

Enoch Nkwe’s appointment as South Africa’s team director is interim — he was in place for the India tour only — and last week CSA suspended director of cricket Corrie van Zyl, another interim appointee, and sponsorship and sales head Clive Eksteen, the only members of their staff who have international playing experience.

Reality will resume after the MSL ends on December 16 — three days before the start of the only remaining round of franchise first-class games before the England series.

Not that there’s certainty that all or even most of the Test players will be in action in those games.

Only half of the 12 fit players who, in India, presided over South Africa’s worst performance in a series in 83 years turned out for their franchises in last week’s first-class matches.

Given all that, cricketminded South Africans will be desperate for a silver lining.

The closest their going to get to that is Hashim Amla’s appointment as the Blitz’ batting consultant, which was announced on Monday.

Like Prince, who faced 100 or more balls in 28 of his 104 Test innings and more than 200 in a dozen of them, suffered only one first-baller — six innings before he retired — and was dismissed in fewer than 10 deliveries just 12 times, Amla valued his wicket greatly.

He was there for at least 100 balls in 61 of 215 trips to the crease, had just 20 innings of fewer than 10 deliveries, and was also out first ball only once — in the first innings of his last Test, when an inswinger from Sri Lanka’s Vishwa Fernando nailed his middle stump.

Contrast that with the facts that 20 of the 60 wickets South Africa lost in India went down in fewer than 10 balls, that only nine times did a player face more than 100 deliveries in the series and only once more than 200 — Dean Elgar’s 160 in the first Test in Visakhapatnam came off 287 balls — and it isn’t difficult to see why Amla’s insight could be important.

That will, hopefully, be the case even though T20 batting is hardly about occupying the crease.

“There’s been a lot of comments lately in the media lately about the lack of our former national players’ involvement in the game,” Prince said when asked about Amla’s involvement.

“I approached him and he was very open to the idea. I don’t think he’s charging us a penny for his services, which is very rare these days.

“To have him share some of his knowledge and ideas would be invaluable.”

What might Blitz captain Quinton de Kock, who shared 125 partnerships with Amla for South Africa across all formats — 13 of them century stands — have learnt from cricket’s calmest player?

“Yoh! There’s a lot he’s taught me,” De Kock said. “I’ve made a lot of mistakes in my career, and he’s been the one guy to be there — backing me and helping me.

“‘Hash’ will know what to do. He will see how he can get the best out of them, whether it’s from a mental or a technical point of view, or just hitting more balls.

“He’s really good at one-on-ones; individual chats rather than in team spaces.”

Warriors coach Robin Peterson thinks so, too. That’s why he enlisted Amla’s help for his team’s first-class match against the Cobras at Newlands last week.

“His manner and the way he talks about batting, he’d be the perfect guy to get the knowledge across,” Peterson said.

Here’s hoping Amla’s wisdom sticks somewhere in the minds of De Kock, Vernon Philander, Anrich Nortjé and George Linde, the Test players in the Blitz squad.

But there’s a catch. Amla will join the side only on November 25.

What’s he doing until then? Playing in something less relevant than even the MSL: the Abu Dhabi T10 League.

Suddenly, that lining is not so silver.

First published by TMG Digital.

SA players struggle to make first-class impact

The argument that the franchise system is where South Africa’s problems start is not as sound as its proponents would have us believe.

TELFORD VICE at Newlands

SOUTH African cricket’s domestic competitions are in as sharp focus as the national team in the wake of the latter’s disastrous Test series in India.

And the former are ahead on the bigger picture’s scoreboard in the current round of franchise first-class matches.

Only six of the dozen fit players who shambled to a 3-0 loss in India are playing for their franchises.

None of them made an impact on the first day’s play on Monday, although only four had the opportunity.

That asks questions of the prevailing view that the quality chasm between domestic and international cricket is an important reason why South Africa were so disappointing against Virat Kohli’s team.

Heinrich Klaasen and Zubayr Hamza did not bat for the Titans and the Cobras on Monday, and in Tuesday’s first session, in their games against the Knights and the Warriors. *

But Senuran Muthusamy did for the Dolphins against the Lions, and managed only 23 off 58 balls in almost two hours before he skied a pull to midwicket.

Lungi Ngidi bowled 13 overs for the Titans and took 1/59.

Dane Piedt had a similar day at the office for the Cobras, claiming 1/57 off 23.

Teammate George Linde went wicketless in nine overs that yielded 22 runs.

None of those performances were particularly poor, but they also didn’t illustrate why the standard in the domestic arena is so far below what it needs to be for South Africa to perform better at international level.

Piedt took another wicket in the morning session on Tuesday, when Linde went to lunch with figures of 3/67.

But Ngidi found no more success in the five overs he bowled, in which he went for 25 runs.

Muthusamy bowled only one over before lunch and conceded three runs.

While all that wasn’t happening, Raynard van Tonder, the Knights’ 21-year-old opening batter, was busy scoring 204.

Five other allegedly lesser lights banked scores of between 61 and 70. 

No doubt the South Africa players are re-adjusting to their home conditions after weeks in the sub-continent, and perhaps they are still recovering from the physical and mental aspects of the beating they took there.

But the argument that the franchise system is where South Africa’s problems start is not as sound as its proponents would like us to believe.

Could it be the other way around — that because South Africa’s players consider themselves so superior to what is seen week in, week out on the country’s major grounds that they don’t pay the domestic game the required respect?

And that, consequently, they are being exposed as arrogant and complacent when they can least afford it?

That’s too neat an explanation, but it deserves to be part of the conversation that cricket in South Africa must have with itself if it is to improve.

* Klaasen was eight not out at stumps, Hamza was caught behind for a fifth-ball duck.

First published by TMG Digital.

SA players conspicuous by first-class absence

“I don’t know a lot about domestic structures because I don’t spend a lot of time in domestic structures.” – Faf du Plessis

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

ONLY six of the 15 players who featured for South Africa in the men’s Test series in India are in action for their franchises in the four-day matches that started on Monday.

Aiden Markram, Dean Elgar and Keshav Maharaj have valid reasons for not playing: they’re injured.

But the rest of the squad who delivered South Africa’s worst series result in 83 years — they lost 3-0, twice by an innings — have a case to answer.

When a team have performed as poorly as they have, in all departments, they least they can do is be seen to be finding answers for their problems.

And especially so when their only available avenue to give a better account of themselves in the series against England, which starts in Centurion on December 26, is to play for their franchises.

But only Heinrich Klaasen, Senuran Muthusamy, Lungi Ngidi, Dane Piedt, Zubayr Hamza and George Linde reported for duty on Monday.

That leaves Faf du Plessis, Temba Bavuma, Theunis de Bruyn, Quinton de Kock, Anrich Nortjé and Vernon Philander up the creek without the paddle of an excuse for not being on the field.

They would have done well to use the downtime to watch Dale Steyn in a television interview on Monday and take seriously what he said: “If you get off that wheel you lose your fitness, you lose your competitive edge and it’s something that I’ve tried to hold on to during the rains here in Cape Town.”

Steyn was talking about the relentlessness needed by players in T20 tournaments, but his words apply as much to South Africa’s current situation.

On his return from India on Friday, Du Plessis told reporters that “I don’t know a lot about domestic structures because I don’t spend a lot of time in domestic structures.”

Whose fault is that? And why did Hashim Amla spend the India series sitting on a couch in SuperSport’s studio rather than playing franchise cricket to make the game stronger? 

“Unfortunately, in South Africa right now, players that retire from international cricket are not going to stay and play domestic cricket,” Du Plessis said. “They will either play overseas or retire completely.

“Hashim Amla and those guys, you can’t expect them to go back and play four-day cricket because they won’t. They won’t do that.

“They’ve been in the international game for so long, they are either going to move on to different pastures — not necessarily greener pastures — but then they will also completely stop.

“I don’t think it’s a real expectation to have, to say those guys must go and play domestic cricket because I don’t think it’s a reality that will most likely ever be met.

“India was a really tough tour mentally, and to just say to the guys, ‘Now you have to go and play’, won’t be the right way to go about it.

“If a guy doesn’t want to go and play what’s the point of him playing. There will be no benefit.”

There has to be a better argument for players not turning out for their franchises than “because they won’t”.

If their bosses — Cricket South Africa — order them to play who are they to say they won’t? 

David Warner had almost a month off after the Ashes. But then he played two Sheffield Shield matches and a one-day game for New South Wales and, four days after that, turned out for Australia again in a T20 against Sri Lanka.

That’s not to suggest Du Plessis doesn’t have a point. Indeed he is his own supporting evidence.

South Africa’s captain was on the field for more than 60% of all the overs bowled in the India series — a heavy physical workload that doesn’t begin to measure the psychological and emotional toll taken on a team so thoroughly beaten.

So maybe South Africa’s players should be cut some slack for their invisibility this week.

But, in the same few days in which their rugby counterparts have scrapped their way into the World Cup final, they can’t expect an easy ride in the public eye.

First published by TMG Digital.

Shake, rattle and Ranchi

South Africa have been outbatted, outfastbowled, outspun, outfielded, outcaptained and outthought.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

THE last time South Africa faced a set of results worse than what looms for their men’s Test team in India on Tuesday, Nelson Mandela had yet to join the ANC.

In March 1936, like they had done in the preceding matches at Newlands and Old Wanderers, Australia won by an innings at Kingsmead to seal a 4-0 series victory.

More than 83 years have passed since South Africa last suffered consecutive innings defeats.

That is likely to change in Ranchi, where the visitors have two wickets in hand to score the 203 runs they need to make India have to bother with batting again in the third and last Test of a rubber that has become ever more wretched for the South Africans.

Having been thrashed by an innings and 137 in the second Test in Pune, which followed a mere drubbing — by 203 runs — in Visakhapatnam, South Africa are staring at a successive defeat in the most humiliating manner.

It would be the ninth time South Africa have slumped to one innings defeat after another, but all of the previous calamities of this calibre were endured while they were lightweights of the international game.

For a side who have spent more than a third of the previous 10 years — 42 of the 120 months — as the No. 1-ranked Test team, and who were still in that spot less than four years ago, this is more a crash than a fall from grace.

They have been outbatted, outfastbowled, outspun, outfielded, outcaptained and outthought. Not forgetting outtossed. Now they are about to be tossed out, of India, and will return home to face England in December.

By then, they will hope, the messy details of what happened on Monday will not be as raw in their consciousness as now.

Having resumed on 9/2 with their hopes of reeling in India’s declaration of 497/9 receding steadily, South Africa were dismissed for 162 in 56.2 overs — both their lowest total of the series and the fewest number of overs they have faced in an innings in the three matches — and followed on 335 behind.

The 91 Zubayr Hamza and Temba Bavuma shared, and the 32 put on by George Linde and Anrich Nortjé, were their only noteworthy partnerships.

Hamza, in only his third Test innings, played like someone with significantly more experience and made a flinty 62.

Bavuma showed familiar stickability for his 32, debutant Linde looked like he belonged for his 37, and Nortjé gutsed it out for 55 balls for his four.

Mohammed Shami seemed to take a particular dislike to Nortjé, hitting him on the shoulder with consecutive bouncers and then nailing his elbow.

Less than three hours after he was dismissed the first time Hamza was back at the crease.

But not for long: he picked the wrong line trying to defend the sixth ball he faced, a sniping outswinger from Shami that sent his off-stump gambolling gaily in the outfield.

“A day of firsts — first half-century for the national side … and the first time I’ve been out twice in the same day,” Hamza mused to reporters in Ranchi after the close.

Quinton de Kock, Hamza, Faf du Plessis, and Bavuma were all out by midway through the 10th over, when Dean Elgar ducked into a bouncer from Umesh Yadav that didn’t get up and was clanged a fearful blow on the side of the helmet.

He shambled off groggily, and South Africa were 67/6 when Theunis de Bruyn walked out as his team’s first ever concussion substitute.

De Bruyn was 30 not out when bad light ended play with South Africa having subsided to 132/8.

This has not been a happy series for De Bruyn, what with him scoring only 52 runs from his first four innings.

But, unlike Hamza, Du Plessis, Bavuma, Heinrich Klaasen, Linde, Dane Piedt and Kagiso Rabada, De Bruyn wasn’t dismissed a second time inside a few hours in which 16 wickets fell.

“To have almost being bowled out twice in just less than two days is pretty poor,” Hamza said.

Mandela, who joined the ANC in 1943, doubtless would have agreed.

First published by TMG Digital.