Unpaid rights could sink MSL’s future

“Paarl Rocks! Paarl Rocks! Paarl Rocks!…” – the passion burns brightly in the Boland.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

IT delivered cricket worth watching, and a lot more. The Mzansi Super League (MSL) took the edge off South Africa’s 3-0 thrashing in a men’s Test series in India in October, and even helped the cricket-minded sections of the country think about something other than how badly the game is being run – into the ground, many would say – by Cricket South Africa’s (CSA) tragicomically inept board. It is no small feat that Russell Adams, CSA’s head of events, and his small army of committed, hard-working zealots made the tournament happen as well as they did despite everything that is wrong with cricket in South Africa.

So it is indeed a pity, then, that we may never see another ball bowled in the tournament. CSA should by now have been paid at least part of the R71-million owed them by Global Sports Commerce (GSC), who held the MSL bundle rights and sold them on. The money has been asked for repeatedly, but the closest CSA have come to getting it is the promise of a meeting on January 28. Cricbuzz have twice sought an explanation from Neekunj Todi, of GSC subsidiary ITW Consultants, who are dealing with CSA on the issue, asking why the money hasn’t been paid and what arrangements are being made to do so. He has not replied.

CSA do not have confidence GSC will cough up. That’s hardly surprising considering Sportsgateway, another GSC subsidiary, are facing an insolvency petition filed in India by FidelisWorld Group for failing to settle a US$4-million arbitration award over a breach of contract in their acquisition of Wisden India.

GSC got an awful lot more bang for their MSL buck than R71-million should have bought them, an indication of the shoddiness of the deal struck by Thabang Moroe, CSA’s now suspended chief executive. The economics of the game in South Africa are cockeyed further by CSA having to pay interim appointees as well as the seven permanent staff who have been suspended. Moroe, for instance, is understood to be on a monthly salary of R350 000, before bonuses, and an annual package of about R5.3-million.

Once production costs are paid, only R40-million of GSM’s cash would go into CSA’s coffers, but the absence of that money would push the MSL’s total losses past R150-million. And that would be damaging enough to prompt CSA to scrap the tournament.

There’s a fan in Paarl who was as happy a human being could safely be when the Rocks beat the Nelson Mandela Bay Giants on December 8, and who would have been happier still, no doubt unsafely, when his team won the final against the Tshwane Spartans on Monday. By the look of him, he didn’t have much in life besides that happiness. How do you tell him it’s gone and not coming back?

He must have been 140 years old. His dreadlocks were as grey as he was gnarled. His once boldly maroon West Indies shirt had faded to watermelon pink, its collar attached by a few threads. His slight, boney frame had all but been swallowed by the bulk of his wheelchair. And there was no escaping him.

“Paarl Rocks! Paarl Rocks! Paarl Rocks!…” His chants were fuelled by mighty shoves of his hands on the wheels of his chair, powering him forward at impressive speed. A collision was unavoidable. Would it be a full frontal clatter of metal on limbs? A knee knackered by a wheel hub? An armrest into the groin?

Happily, he had the skills to melt the moment into a high five, extending a vast hand whose leatheriness told of a life lived hard. That hand’s warmth was beautiful. With that he was gone, onward and upward and through the gaps between the thousands around him also celebrating victory, dispensing vast, leathery, warm, beautiful high fives as he went.

“Paarl Rocks! Paarl Rocks! Paarl Rocks!…”

The Rocks had scrapped their way to a 12-run win that sealed a home final and sent the Giants home to play in the eliminator against the Spartans. It was the drama that started with Faf du Plessis, the Rocks’ captain, talking about his XI at the toss: “One change. Hardus Viljoen is not playing today because he’s lying in bed with my sister [Remi Rhynners]; they got married yesterday.” It ended in a verbal altercation between players from opposing teams on the balcony that needed the intervention of cooler heads to stop the silliness from turning physical.

Clearly, players and public alike have come to care about the MSL. This year’s tournament began in front of only 2 800 spectators at the Wanderers on November 8, even though Kagiso Rabada, Chris Gayle and Quinton de Kock were in action, and took 10 games – three of them among the total of eight washouts – to draw a crowd of 5 000. It reached its climax with the approving roars of 7 500 delirious Rocks supporters who had come not to see the Spartans’ AB de Villiers but to cheer their team to the tree tops. There would have been exponentially more at the final, but that’s as many as Paarl’s picturesque but pintsized ground can hold.

“If the cricket world didn’t know of the Boland community from the Western Cape before, then they certainly do now with their enthusiastic support throughout this tournament,” Adams was quoted as saying in a justifiably rah-rah release.

The past few weeks have sparkled with snapshots like Tabraiz Shamsi conjuring magic tricks on the field in the afterglow of producing magical deliveries, Ben Dunk — can there be a more Australian name? — talking faster than he scored in his 54-ball 99 not out against the Spartans, and ancients like Dale Steyn and Imran Tahir bowling back the years.

The first tournament had been uncertainly received, like a second-hand car that doesn’t drive as well as it gleamed in the showroom. Just a year later fans own their teams like heirlooms to be passed on; particularly in Paarl and Port Elizabeth, which is part of Nelson Mandela Bay. The MSL shouldn’t exist considering its mounting losses, but it has become that elusive thing essential to its survival and, eventually, its prosperity: real.

First published by Cricbuzz.

MSL catches fire in PE

As a window into what the MSL could be if major players in the sponsorship and broadcast world were able to have confidence that it was a good place to spend their money, it was bittersweet.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

THE Mzansi Super League (MSL) took the edge off its problems by delivering the closest game yet in this year’s competition at St George’s Park on Wednesday.

Plagued by inadequate sponsorship and broadcast revenue, ineffective marketing, little prospect of breaking even, and tiny crowds, the MSL doesn’t have much going for it.

But, for three or so hours while the Nelson Mandela Bay Giants and the Cape Town Blitz conjured a contest for the ages, none of that mattered as acutely.

The Blitz put up a decent 186/9 — the Warriors’ 189 against the Cobras in April is the only higher T20 first innings at this ground, and remains the record total — and the Giants reeled it in with five wickets standing and four balls to spare.

Janneman Malan and Quinton de Kock shared 72 for the first wicket for the second time in the tournament in scoring 31 and 39, and the rest of the visitors’ top five — Marques Ackerman, Liam Livingstone and Asif Ali — added another 87 to the total.

But the Giants fought back, taking 5/22 to limit the damage effectively.

Chris Morris, Junior Dala, Imran Tahir and Onke Nyaku claimed two wickets each with Tahir’s 2/26 and economy rate of 6.50 the standout showing.

The Giants seemed sunk without trace after only nine balls, what with openers Matthew Breetzke and Jason Roy gone with just three runs scored.

But captain Jon-Jon Smuts stood tall through partnerships of 53 with Ben Dunk, 46 with Heino Kuhn and 48 with Marco Marais before slashing a catch to backward point to go for a 51-ball 73.

Smuts’ gutsy effort included a reprieve for a no-ball dismissal by Wahab Riaz and surviving a lengthy review for a catch by George Linde at short fine leg off Sisanda Magala.

His exit, forced by a near no-ball from Wahab, left Marais — the cleanest, crispest, hardest hitter in South African cricket since Rassie van der Dussen — and Morris to get the job done, which they did by clattering 37 off 18 balls.

Morris clinched it in soap opera style with a mighty heave off Magala, which Linde, diving for all his worth on the midwicket fence, almost caught.

Instead the ball was deflected onto the boundary cushion, which cost the Blitz six runs, the match, and their position at the top of the standings — a spot now occupied by the Giants.

As a game of cricket it was the stuff of dreams: dramatic and intensely competitive with a fair sprinkling of quality individual performances.

As a window into what the tournament could be if major players in the sponsorship and broadcast world were able to have confidence that the MSL was a good place to spend their money, it was bittersweet.

Reality resumed, and with it an interview Hashim Amla gave to Pakistani website PakPassion.

“I find it very amusing whenever this whole subject of Kolpak and its effects on South African cricket are brought up,” Amla was quoted as saying.

“Kolpak has been around for a long time, and so it’s surprising to me that it is been touted as the reason for all evils only because we lost the recent Test series to India [3-0 in October].

“I do not want this idea to become a convenient excuse for what basically were bad performances against India.

“When I was playing domestic cricket, we had quite a number of Kolpak players in our domestic teams also but then there was no talk of this subject.

“Let’s be honest about it, India are a really good side and they will probably beat all teams at home and the fact is that we did not play that well during the tour.

“Now one may argue that I am saying this because I have signed to play for Surrey next year as a Kolpak player but my story is slightly different as I have a few years of international cricket under my belt.

“The fact remains that this whole issue has gained importance just due to recent bad performances.”

Amla spoke from the United Arab Emirates, where he is playing for the Karnataka Tuskers in the Abu Dhabi T10 — a fact that on its own is indicative of some of South African cricket’s problems beyond Kolpak.

Having served as the Blitz’ batting consultant, free of charge, Amla has done his bit for the MSL.

But, if the game was in better shape at home, wouldn’t he prefer playing in the MSL to some gimmick far away?

You didn’t need to be at St George’s Park on Wednesday to answer that question.

First published by TMG Digital.