Rassie van der Dussen, meet Bishan Singh Bedi

“The situations we faced in the past four years – COVID, Black Lives Matter, SJN – various political stories that we’ve had to manage as a team, have really forced us to pull together.” – Rassie van der Dussen

Telford Vice / Pune

RASSIE van der Dussen, meet Bishan Singh Bedi. You will have so much to talk about that your conversation will soar through and beyond mere cricket. You won’t agree on everything — that would be boring, anyway — but by the time you say goodbye you will have made not only a friend but a comrade.

Sadly, as of last Monday, when Bedi died in Delhi, this connection is no longer possible. That they never met is indeed a pity, because Bedi was that rare creature in cricket, regardless of the era: a player who thought about and spoke about matters far away from the game. His boundary wasn’t the edge of the ground. It was the full extent of what it meant to live, with integrity, in this imperfect world. Van der Dussen is of the same mind.

Which is not to conflate them as cricketers. Bedi’s bowling action was fluid simplicity in motion, the game’s equivalent of Picasso’s lifelong yearning to paint like a child. Van der Dussen’s batting technique can look as if it’s been cobbled together by a committee for the preservation of ungainliness. And yet, just as the product of Bedi’s apparently beach cricket action was the undoing of the world’s top batters, so Van der Dussen’s spiky angularity reaps runs and adds rectitude to South Africa’s batting.

He is their compass at the crease, just as a lodestone guides him off the field. As with Bedi, Van der Dussen’s boundary encircles everything. His answer, at a press conference in Pune on Tuesday when he was asked what had changed for South Africa’s team — who have won five of their first six games at this World Cup — since the 2019 edition, when they lost five of their eight completed matches, said as much.

“I think the situations we faced in the past four years, whether it be COVID, whether it be Black Lives Matter, SJN [CSA’s Social Justice and Nation-Building project, which exposed deep rooted racism in the game], various political stories that we’ve had to manage as a team, have really forced us to pull together.

“And the effect of us being really tight off the field, knowing each other intimately. We’ve been playing together for a very long time. Between any two members of the squad there’s a real connection somewhere. So I think there’s definitely something different in this team. We’ve had to deal with quite a lot of controversy and that’s stood us in good stead.”

A lot of that would seem to have nothing to do with scoring runs and taking wickets. But, because cricket is part of the real world and not the other way round, those who need to score runs and take wickets will be thrown this way and that by the impact of events beyond the edge of the ground. 

Van der Dussen, like Bedi, is not among the unfortunates who believe in the impossibility that sport should be sacrosanct and separate from everything around it. The reaction to South Africa’s loss to the Netherlands on October 17, which leapt far past Dharamsala’s confines, proved that. 

“You realise there are people at home who’ve been scarred by South Africa’s performances at World Cups,” Van der Dussen said. “And you can’t criticise them for feeling that way — it’s criticism coming from a place of hurt; they’ve seen that movie before. But we haven’t lived that, so it’s not really applicable to us and it’s not affecting us. It’s part of history but it’s certainly not part of us as a team.”

That history is starkly different to the Springboks’, who have returned home to the adulation of their compatriots after winning the rugby World Cup for a record fourth time. The Boks have yet to lose a final. The Proteas have yet to reach a final. That’s a bleak view from the cricket end of the equation, but Van der Dussen said the team were “massively” inspired by their rugby counterparts.

“I think Siya [Kolisi, the Springbok captain] mentioned in a press conference that if you’re not from South Africa you don’t really understand what sporting achievements mean for the people at home and for us. The realisation for us is that we’re no different. Yes, we haven’t won World Cups. But if we do manage to get there it will be an honour for us to be mentioned in the same sentence as those guys.”

What did it mean for Van der Dussen to represent not a country where realities are less contested, or problems are on a smaller scale, or the future seems stable? What did it mean to play, instead, for South Africa’s teams? 

“We come from a very divided background, and that sort of mindset is still entrenched in a lot of communities and among a lot of the older generation. What the Springboks and what sport shows us is that, as South Africans, when you do get things right and you do things the right way, what you can achieve. Good things happen to good people. That Springbok team, that’s what they are. They’re all hardworking, good South Africans with a real humility about them, a real hunger for success. It shows, when you’re willing to put differences aside, what’s possible for a country like ours.”

At 34, Van der Dussen lives in a South Africa he knows is at once different and similar to what it was under apartheid. Gerald Coetzee, 11 years Van der Dussen’s junior, is from a different time and, in some senses, a different place. “We’ve grown up to understand each other’s cultures, and when we don’t understand something we try to respect it,” Coetzee said. “Because when you don’t understand something you still need to respect it.”

Coetzee “can’t imagine how hard it must have been” to live and play sport under apartheid, “but our cricket heritage is old and we look up to those players. So as much as the politics was horrible, the players were decent. There’s a balance — looking at the cricketers we’ve produced over the years and being proud of that; also looking at the history and being sad. But also rejoicing about that it’s become so much better and there’s been so much growth. We need to look at that and appreciate it.”

Had Bedi, a cricketer’s cricketer who was so much more than a cricketer, still been with us it would be difficult not to imagine him nodding and smiling in approval. This, he might have said, is how life is supposed to work: one generation making it better for the next.

Before India visited South Africa for the first time from November 1992 to January 1993 — when apartheid was dying but still the law of the land — Bedi, then 47 and long retired, asked Vijay Lokapally, a stalwart Indian journalist who was to cover that tour, “to get literature on South Africa the country and on South African cricket”, Lokapally said. “Bedi sir felt strongly for the blacks. He particularly wanted books that had information on the apartheid days.” When Lokapally returned home Bedi invited him to lunch and a debrief: “He listened to my experiences with childlike enthusiasm. He wanted to know if I had experienced any discrimination because of my colour.”

Famously, Bedi wrote to the Delhi and District Cricket Association (DDCA) to demand his name be removed from a stand at the Kotla after the ground was relabelled in honour of Arun Jaitley, a former DDCA president and BCCI vice-president but more prominent as India’s minister of finance. To be connected with a figure he detested was too much for Bedi, whose letter scathed: “With honour comes responsibility. They fêted me for the total respect and integrity with which I played the game. And now I’m returning the honour to assure them all that four decades after my retirement, I still retain those values.” As if that wasn’t clear enough, he followed up with another volley days later: “I don’t wish a stand in my name when late Arun Jaitley’s statue is erected without any visible shame.”

Even so, the Bishan Singh Bedi Stand still hugs the western boundary in Delhi, offering spectators respite from the setting sun. Cheers rose from those in its seats on October 7 — 16 days before Bedi’s death — when South Africa piled up 428/5 to beat Sri Lanka by 102 runs. Quinton de Kock and Aiden scored centuries, but so did a player who isn’t blessed with their languid left-handedness, a man of angles, integrity, and the courage to speak his mind. Maybe, in cricket’s strange way, Van der Dussen did meet Bedi after all. 

Cricbuzz

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Little obvious about England, South Africa ‘knockout’

“We believe in you guys. We trust you guys. One hiccup, but you know what to do.” – Siya Kolisi’s message to South Africa’s team.

Telford Vice / Mumbai

AS they do when they bat, players tend to use triggers when they talk to the press. At the crease they use short, sharp movements — their back foot moving across the stumps as the bowler reaches their delivery stride, for instance. In front of the microphones they say the same word in answering different questions, usually to buy a moment’s time to mentally polish their responses.

Jos Buttler’s trigger word is “obviously”. He deployed it nine times in his short press conference on Friday, usually to buy a moment’s time to mentally polish his answers to questions.

The care and effort to take these things seriously is appreciated; Buttler is among cricket’s more articulate and thoughtful press conference victims. But the admittedly weak joke is on him: little is obvious about England’s World Cup match against South Africa at the Wankhede on Saturday.

England lost to Afghanistan in Delhi on Sunday, and South Africa to the Netherlands in Dharamsala on Tuesday. That followed England’s defeat to New Zealand and their win over Bangladesh, and South Africa’s successes over Sri Lanka and Australia. Clear as mud, innit?

What is crystal is that Saturday’s match looms as a knockout game in all but official status. Another win and the campaign will be resurrected. Another loss, especially for England, and thoughts will turn to a long and draining traipse around India waiting to be one of the six sides who will be eliminated after the league stage. A dead team walking, you might say.

South Africa’s chances of doing so seemed to suffer a setback when Heinrich Klaasen went down, courtesy of a tasty tackle by David Miller, in a game of warm-up football on the Wankhede’s outfield ahead of Friday evening’s training session. But, after a long moment spent sitting on the turf, with Miller in close and perhaps anxious attendance, Klaasen rose and got on with things. Then Quinton de Kock took the nets, which he rarely does in optional sessions. And then Miller sent a ball arching from the middle many metres in the muggy air, over the straight boundary and over 14 rows of seats and into the reassuringly thick plate glass that fronts the pressbox. Nuggets of apparent nothingness like those are magnified in the context of matches as big as this.  

The South Africans won’t be under only the, ahem, obvious pressure. The match will end hours before the Springboks play England in Paris in a rugby World Cup semifinal. The Boks have won three World Cups, the Proteas none. The Boks have never lost a final. The Proteas have never reached a final.

So it meant something that Springbok captain Siya Kolisi took time out of his team’s preparations for the match to send his cricketing counterparts a video. “We believe in you guys,” Kolisi said as he stood next to head coach Jacques Nienaber. “We trust you guys. One hiccup, but you know what to do. Enjoy it and play as hard as you can. You know that over 60-million South Africans will be supporting you, including us. So make it special.”

The significant coincidence wasn’t lost on Temba Bavuma, who said at his press conference: “It doesn’t happen often that two sports converge in a global product like they will do this weekend. There’s a lot of excitement about Super Saturday in South Africa. It’s extra context to add to what is going to be a crucial battle. A lot of us love our rugby so we’ll definitely be supporting the Springboks. We play first so the responsibility’s on us to put smiles on our compatriots’ faces, make sure we go out and entertain. And bring back the win.”

Bavuma also used a verbal trigger in his press conference. It was also “obviously”, and he also deployed it nine times. That’s how little there is to separate England and South Africa. 

When: October 21, 2023 at 14:00 IST

Where: Wankhede Stadium, Mumbai

What to expect: The Indian Meteorological Department has issued a red alert about Cyclone Tej, which is due to hit Mumbai in the next 48 hours. But the usual suspect weather forecasts don’t mention it affecting Maximum City much. Go figure. The pitch is more predictable: red soil, so the fast bowlers’ and big hitters’ friend.  

Teams:

England

Big Ben’s back. Ben Stokes, that is, who has recovered from a hip problem and is expected to play his first match of the tournament. Half of Ben Stokes, anyway: he won’t bowl. Even so, 50% of a talismanic allrounder is better than none.

As many seamers as possible seems to be the goal. But which seamers? Sam Curran, England’s worst performing quick in the tournament, could make way for David Willey. Stokes’ inclusion might come at the expense of Adil Rashid, leaving Joe Root to do the spinner’s job.

Tactics & strategy

It’s complicated. A side who have played compellingly simple cricket for years face questions on multiple fronts. The most pressing among them is where did England’s get up and go get up and go to? Their previous impressive decisiveness was missing for much of their first three games, but the fact that their top three of Jonny Bairstow, Dawid Malan and Joe Root made two 50s and century between them against Bangladesh in Dharamsala in their most recent match, when Reece Topley took 4/43, suggests improvement.

Probable XI: Jonny Bairstow, Dawid Malan, Joe Root, Jos Buttler (capt), Harry Brook, Ben Stokes, Liam Livingstone, David Willey, Chris Woakes, Mark Wood, Reece Topley

South Africa

It would seem surprising that an XI who were properly beaten in their previous match should be retained, but that’s likely. South Africa’s choice throughout the tournament will be between Gerald Coetzee and Tabraiz Shamsi, and Coetzee looks set to crack the nod this time.

Tactics & strategy

Bat big, try to bowl at least as big. If South Africa have a weakness it’s with ball in hand. The Dutch proved that by hitting and hustling 104 off the last nine overs. The batting is under less scrutiny, but the World Cup’s most hyped top six will be stung at having been reduced to 44/4 by the Netherlands.  

Probable XI: Temba Bavuma (capt), Quinton de Kock, Rassie van der Dussen, Aiden Markram, Heinrich Klaasen, David Miller, Marco Jansen, Kagiso Rabada, Keshav Maharaj, Gerald Coetzee, Lungi Ngidi

Did you know?

— Ben Stokes starred in his only World Cup match against South Africa, at the Oval in 2019, by scoring 89 off 79, taking 2/12 in 17 deliveries, and claiming two catches — one of them an outrageous diving reverse-cup miracle on the midwicket fence to remove Andile Phehlukwayo.

— Seven of the England XI who played in the teams’ 2019 World Cup clash are in the current squad, versus six of South Africa’s. The absentees include luminaries like Eoin Morgan, Jofra Archer, Hashim Amla, Faf du Plessis and Imran Tahir. 

— England haven’t lost a World Cup match against South Africa since 2007, when the South Africans earned their third victory in as many tournaments against them.

What they said:

“Ben trained really well last night. It’s great to see him back. He obviously brings a lot on the field and with his presence and leadership skills as well as someone who is always good to turn to. He adds a lot of value.” — Jos Buttler on Ben Stokes’ return.

“Our biggest misdemeanour as batters is that we took the negative energy from the field, the momentum that the Netherlands guys had achieved at the end of their innings, into our batting.” — Temba Bavuma on what South Africa will try not to repeat against England.

Squads: 

England: Jos Buttler (capt), Moeen Ali, Gus Atkinson, Jonny Bairstow, Sam Curran, Liam Livingstone, Dawid Malan, Adil Rashid, Joe Root, Harry Brook, Ben Stokes, Reece Topley, David Willey, Mark Wood, Chris Woakes

South Africa: Temba Bavuma (capt), Reeza Hendricks, Aiden Markram, David Miller, Rassie van der Dussen, Marco Jansen, Andile Phehlukwayo, Quinton de Kock, Heinrich Klaasen, Gerald Coetzee, Keshav Maharaj, Lungi Ngidi, Kagiso Rabada, Tabraiz Shamsi, Lizaad Williams

Cricbuzz

Fiction becomes fact at Newlands

It was almost a pity that a cricket match had to be played.

Telford Vice / Newlands

A woman who had lived more than a few years of life made her way carefully down the stairs separating the lower reaches of blocks D and E in a stand beyond Newlands’ eastern boundary on Sunday.

A light south-easter plucked at her black-and-white dress and white hijab as she went. Her walking stick steadied her every step. She was bound for block E, row J, seat No. 1. Once she had made that effort, she eased into her seat and settled in, her brown face beaming gently at the vividly green field in front of her, the scene bathed in the bright but no longer hot sun of late summer.

In seat No. 2 was a young black woman in a tight, sleeveless top wearing her dusty pink hair short in a pouffy style. More contrasting neighbours would be difficult to find. A black man of similar age to No. 2 was in seat No. 3. Clearly, Nos. 2 and 3 knew each other.

Directly in front of them, in row H, the first seat was occupied by a youngish brown woman who chatted with, to her left, a white woman and, in seat No. 3, a willowy white man wearing John Lennon-style sunglasses under his floppy fringe. The women sported blondish twin ponytails. All were about the same age.

On a stage a hundred or so metres away, Mi Casa, a popular house trio, were oozing through their set. They are fronted by a white man born in Portugal who moved to Port Alfred in the Eastern Cape as a child. The other two members are black men with strong roots in the music scene. One played in his first band at the age of eight. The other’s father was part of Mango Groove, a pop group prominent in the 1980s.

A world away from all that in the President’s Suite, arrangements were being made for the arrival of the man himself, Cyril Ramaphosa. Siya Kolisi and Francois Pienaar, who know a thing or two about winning World Cups with the Springboks, were already there. So was Graeme Smith, who despite his best efforts knows a thing or five about not winning World Cups.

It was just less than an hour before the start of the women’s T20 World Cup final, and it was almost a pity that a cricket match had to be played. South Africa’s society is riven by division so deep that television commercials advertising a particular brand of beer are perennially ridiculed for promoting a fiction of togetherness because they feature people of all races and cultures choosing to spend time together.

So to see exactly that, live, in person and for real, at a sold out Newlands on Sunday tugged at the tearstrings of many South Africans long before the anthems were played, when they flowed freely from even the most cynical eyes. And doubtless also from the woman in block E, row J, seat No. 1.

Cricbuzz

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Hain hits SA where it hurts

“I would have thought the one set of sportspeople in the world who should have been taking the knee was in South Africa.” – Peter Hain

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

THE refusal by South Africa’s men’s cricket team to take a knee in support of racial justice has been slammed by noted anti-apartheid campaigner Peter Hain. Teams from several other countries have offered the gesture in recent months, as have figures in a range of different sports. But not the XI representing the country where the legacy of apartheid continues to determine the course of millions of lives based on their race.

During the T20I series against England, banners at Newlands proclaimed: “We stand in solidarity against racism and gender based violence. CSA stands for equality.” The players themselves have done nothing beyond release a powerful statement outlining their commitment to anti-racism.

Asked on Wednesday if he was disappointed by the team’s lack of action, Hain said: “Yes, I am, to be frank. Because I would have thought, of all countries in the world, given the history of apartheid and the legacy of apartheid that still is with us [they would take a knee].

“Siya Kolisi only became the Springbok captain [who led his team to triumph at the 2019 men’s World Cup] because he went to Grey [High School]. He was plucked out of the township and poverty where he wasn’t getting a decent meal a day to become one of the best internationals in the world.

“So the legacy is still there, and I would have thought the one set of sportspeople in the world who should have been taking the knee was in South Africa; to send a signal to the world that South Africa actually understood its apartheid history.

“What’s struck me about the contemporary debate, especially around cricket, is that attitudes among some of the white cricketers haven’t changed. Viewed from outside, it’s as if people simply haven’t imbibed the nature of change.” 

Nairobi-born Hain was raised in South Africa until, in 1966 when he was 16, his parents moved the family to the United Kingdom to escape harassment and persecution from the apartheid state for their activism against the regime. There he led protests against tours by South Africa’s all-white teams, and later became a Labour member of parliament and a cabinet minister.

He was speaking at a webinar to promote a new book, “Pitch Battle: Sport, Racism and Resistance”, which he has co-authored with André Odendaal, a cricket historian and administrator. The work’s publication next Tuesday might seem timed to coincide with the rise of Black Lives Matter (BLM), which has gained prominence in the wake of George Floyd’s killing by police in Minneapolis on May 25 this year.

Odendaal said it was the other way around: “We were trying to explain how systemic racism developed in sport, and BLM broke out as we were writing the concluding pages. Together with the pandemic, that delayed our book by six months. But it enabled us to end it in a very relevant way.

“This is a time when we must rethink; rethink how the world works after Covid-19 and also rethink how sport works and the tremendous shortcomings there have been in the decolonisation project. We’re talking about 500 years of systemic violence with these ideas of discrimination and exclusion that have developed in our country particularly in the last 200 years since sport took on its modern form. It’s a good time, in new languages and new contexts, with young people asking questions, to revisit where we are and what we can learn from the struggles that went before.”

Odendaal is part of CSA’s interim board, which has been compiled with the help of government.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Race wounds still raw in South African cricket

“Those injustices were done to us as blacks. I doubt that any white player out there has ever been called a monkey.” – Geoff Toyana

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

A statement on Tuesday in support of Lungi Ngidi’s stance on the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement has thrown into stark relief the gaping racial divisions in South African cricket. The release lists 31 former players and five current coaches as signatories. Not one of them is white. Neither have any white current or former national players volunteered their backing for Ngidi.

The document, which former Titans player and Lions coach Geoff Toyana told Cricbuzz was the work of “a collective”, seeks to “invite our fellow white cricketers to join in this move to defend human dignity”. Had any whites been approached to back the initiative? “No, but that’s a very good question,” Toyana said. “Those injustices were done to us as blacks. I doubt that any white player out there has ever been called a monkey.”

The atmosphere around the game has been racially charged in the wake of Ngidi being asked, during an online press conference last Monday, whether South Africa’s current players were talking about supporting BLM. “That’s definitely something that we will discuss once we are together in person,” he said. “We have spoken about it and everyone is well aware of what’s going on. It’s a difficult one because we are not together, so it’s hard to discuss. But once we get back to playing that is definitely something we have to address as a team.

“As a nation as well, we have a past that is very difficult because of racial discrimination. So it’s definitely something we will be addressing as a team and if we are not, it’s something I will bring up. It’s something that we need to take very seriously and, like the rest of the world is doing, make a stand.”

That earned Ngidi disapproval from former white players, who with no apparent evidence took his view to mean he was telling his peers what to do. “What nonsense is this,” Pat Symcox posted on social media. “[Ngidi] must take his own stand if he wishes. Stop trying to get the Proteas involved in his belief.”

In perhaps the only note of notable white support for Ngidi, Vince van der Bijl, a former fast bowler, disagreed: “BLM does not say other lives don’t matter … Respect is allowing others to have their opinions. You are allowed yours. We do not have the space to state all the things that we talk about. And agree on. Saying one thing does not exclude other beliefs. We ache for so many things in this country. Hopefully we can help the healing as opposed to widen the divides.”

Tuesday’s statement said: “We note … that the most outspoken criticism directed at Ngidi has come via former players such as Pat Symcox, Boeta Dippenaar, Rudi Steyn, Brian McMillan and others, and we urge that their views be challenged. We are not surprised at their comments.

“Given South Africa’s well-known past, black cricketers have borne the brunt of subtle and overt racist behaviour for many years, including from some colleagues. Consequently, there is a need to understand how white privilege feeds into the perpetuation of these old attitudes and assumptions. 

“Our attitude, mistakenly, we now believe, has always been to say: ‘These are teething problems, and that these will be resolved if we are patient’. But after almost three decades of cricket unity, the views expressed from one side of the racial divide are still very much part of our lives, and we now believe: ‘Teething problems cannot be allowed to continue for this long’ …

“We represent, or have represented, South Africa on merit. Far too many white South Africans cannot accept that black cricketers have proved, time without end, that they are good enough to play at the highest level.”

South Africa’s 2019 rugby World Cup triumph, achieved with a squad captained by the black Siya Kolisi and that included 11 black or brown players — six of whom started the final — was proof that diversity bred strength, the statement said. 

“We want to remind South Africans that, as recently as 2017, we were told that a South African sister sport, rugby, was ‘dead’ — killed by ‘transformation’. But guess what? South African rugby won a World Cup last year. We cannot recall anyone suggesting that the victory was due to transformation. Why is transformation always rammed down the throats of national teams when they lose, but never when they win?

“… We are determined that future generations should not have to experience the pain we have had to endure, and that no South African cricketer should be discriminated against in the future. Racism is a global problem and, as the great Michael Holding explained, we can no longer just keep on laughing, grimacing and moving on.”

Former Test fast bowler Holding, now a television commentator, made an impassioned plea for racial justice last week during coverage of the first Test between England and West Indies in Southampton.

Racial unity in South African cricket was proclaimed in 1991, but the game continues to struggle to properly represent the country’s black and brown people — who make up more than 90% of the population — on the field. Of the country’s 345 men’s Test players, 316 — more than 90% — have been white. 

Makhaya Ntini, the only one among South Africa’s nine black Test players to earn 50 or more caps, was among the signatories of Tuesday’s release. The brown Hashim Amla, who played 124 Tests, was not. Neither was the brown Russell Domingo, the first South Africa head coach who is not white.

Such colour coding is grim. Not that it was, for the first 100 years and more of cricket’s history in South Africa, difficult to say which race was winning. But the match situation is changing — to the chagrin of some, not nearly quickly enough for others. Who’s winning now? That’s difficult to say, but this struggle is a long way from decided. 

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Time to walk the revolution talk

Not for Siya Kolisi the premature congratulations being lavished on Graeme Smith, Mark Boucher and Jacques Kallis. 

TELFORD VICE in Johannesburg

THE motorway exit to Centurion is still named after John Vorster, one of apartheid’s most brutal enforcers. The sun still hammers down on the scene with apparent hatred for all beneath it. The pitch, two days before the first ball is bowled in the men’s Test series between South Africa and England, is still the colour of the inside of a freshly halved avocado. But everything else has changed.

“There’s a real energy in the squad, a real positive feel to what we’ve been doing and how we’ve been training the last week and the information that’s been spoken about with Kallis and Boucher back in the team,” Faf du Plessis said on Tuesday. “Even with someone like myself, who’s played a lot of international cricket, the wisdom that’s in the dressingroom helps me as well.”

That’s batting consultant Jacques Kallis and head coach Mark Boucher he’s talking about, who along with Graeme Smith — the acting director of cricket — have pulled cricket in South Africa out of the terminal nosedive it was forced into by months of damagingly shambolic administration at board and operational level.

“The last six months it has felt as if there is more weight on my shoulders,” Du Plessis said. “I could see so many things happening off the field; not the right structures being put in place. That’s never an excuse for the type of cricket that we play. But it has been a breath of fresh air to have these guys back. Why have these guys not been here for the last 10 years? It’s so important to have people like that in an international dressingroom. When we played against the Australians [at the World Cup], you look at [Justin] Langer, [Ricky] Ponting, [Steve] Waugh … We want that.”

But how can we say conclusively that Smith, Boucher and Kallis have cleaned up the mess South Africa were in their Test series in India in October and at the World Cup when we have yet to see the product of their efforts? They’ve been aboard for so short a time — Smith’s appointment was announced on December 11, Boucher’s three days later, Kallis’ and bowling consultant Charl Langeveldt’s four days after that — and South Africa’s problems run so deep — batting, bowling, fielding, thinking, even the toss — that it is fatuous to think the issues have been solved at a stroke, or three, and even if the recent appointments bring with them 1,420 international caps worth of experience. Yet cricketminded South Africans do think they are the answer, and are saying so — perhaps because the hole the game has crashed into is so unprecedentedly deep that any way is up.

So it seems unfair that it falls to Du Plessis’ and his players to validate the narrative that everything is going to be OK now that South Africa’s relatively illustrious past has been called back. Except that, as the above attests, the team — or those members of it who have spoken to the press since the dressingroom revolution — have been cheerleaders-in-chief for the new deal. Du Plessis knows that push will come to shove as soon as 10am on Thursday: “Whatever we do before a Test series means nothing. We will get measured on the way we play. Now it’s about going out there and putting in performances on the field.”

It would be interesting to know whether Du Plessis’ true feelings about someone who was in a similarly bleak place 18 months ago, a man he calls his friend. A funny thing happened on the way to that friend being tossed onto the scrapheap of South Africa’s history: he led the Springboks to triumph at rugby’s World Cup. Does Du Plessis envy or admire Siya Kolisi, or perhaps harbour elements of both emotions? Maybe cricket should pause on its road to redemption and ask itself those questions, and should stop at Kolisi’s door and listen to his advice.

Du Plessis and Kolisi were having dinner together in Cape Town last month when a familiar figure spotted the latter and came over to their table. It turns out Jurgen Klopp, the Liverpool football manager, is a Kolisi fan. Who isn’t? Kolisi rose from a background exponentially less privileged than Du Plessis’ to conquer his world. He emerged from a system that was broken and played an important role in fixing it, and did so to the disbelief of legions who thought he was part of the problem. Not for Kolisi the premature congratulations being lavished on Smith, Boucher and Kallis. 

In the course of relating the dinner story to the press on Tuesday, Du Plessis was asked whether Klopp had also recognised him. “No,” was his comfortably modest response. Taking a Test series off England, which no South men’s team have done at home since January 2000, won’t change that. But it could be the start of everything truly changing.

First published by Cricbuzz. 

Cricket needs rugby’s radicalism

“Cricket were ahead of rugby. Have cricket taken their eye off the ball? I don’t know.” – teacher and rugby zealot Brendan Fogarty.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

MAYBE Kagiso Rabada should have heeded the signs and not veered off his original path.

Rabada was born on May 25, 1995 — the same day Francois Pienaar’s team started their journey to World Cup glory by beating the Wallabies at Newlands. He arrived at St Stithians as a hotshot fullback.

Had he not kicked rugby into touch for a future in fast bowling, might he have been welcomed back to Cape Town on Monday among Siya Kolisi’s heroes to help thousands of their compatriots celebrate the Springboks winning the William Webb Ellis Cup for the third time?

Rabada has been the top ranked bowler in the world in two of the three formats, and is currently in the top five in both. He is also one of the 66 unfortunates who have tried and failed to claim a single men’s cricket World Cup for South Africa.

Clearly, rugby is getting a lot right. Just as clearly, cricket is doing something wrong. But what?

“There’s too much emphasis on racialism, on certain groups needing to be there,” Cassiem Jabbar said as the crowd awaiting the Boks grew outside Cape Town’s city hall.

“I believe that this Springbok team was there on merit. I don’t think there’s any other wings that we could have chosen for South Africa, or any other front row forwards.

“We are past the stage were we talk about quota players and players of colour.

“Some people are still stuck in that conversation.”

Cricket people included, and specifically the prevailing philosophy that some black people are blacker than others and thus more deserving of opportunities.

It was a radical statement coming from someone who might have been recognised as the best scrumhalf in the world had he not been guilty of playing rugby while black during apartheid.

Surely there is more to South Africa’s perennial failure to launch at cricket World Cup’s than an obsession — mostly healthy and necessary, sometimes damaging and dangerous — with colour coding?

“It’s not about plucking talent and putting it into [elite] schools,” Brendan Fogarty said. “We need to invest in communities to ensure that that talent grows in those communities.

“Cricket were ahead of rugby, when you look at programmes like Baker’s Mini-Cricket. Have cricket taken their eye off the ball? I don’t know. But you need a thousand children playing rugby to create one international.

“So if you’re taking a talented player out of a community, that community might not play anymore. We need to have communities, in their thousands, playing cricket. It’s a numbers game.”

That, too, is radical. Fogarty is an isiXhosa teacher at Bishops Preparatory School — about as elite as schools get. But he also runs the Vusa rugby development programme, which counts Springbok and Stormers flank Sikhumbuzo Notshe as an alumnus.

A much highlighted feature of the Boks’ success is that their players come from more than the familiar crop of schools.

Cricket has and is making sincere attempts to spread the gospel. But, of the 16 SA-born Proteas in the 2019 World Cup, only Beuran Hendricks did not attend a high school that has an illustrious sporting history. And Good Hope Seminary School in Gardens is hardly an impoverished township alma mater.

Maybe what cricket needs is what rugby has embraced: radicalism.

First published by the Sunday Times.

CSA miss own deadline on Cobras transformation issue

“I can’t comment on what goes on right at the top but I can certainly say there’s great talent in South Africa.” – Robin Peterson focuses on the positive.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

CRICKET South Africa (CSA) seem set to miss their self-imposed deadline for getting to the bottom of a transformation target transgression last month.

The Cobras’ XI for their first-class fixture against the Warriors at Newlands included seven black players — one more than the stipulated number.

But only two of them, fast bowlers Thando Ntini and Tladi Bokako, were black African — one fewer than the target.

“CSA has noted the submission by Western Cape Cricket [WCC] in lieu of a request for a deviation from the administrative conditions,” a CSA spokesperson said at the time.

But, according to Cobras coach Ashwell Prince, there was nothing “in lieu” about how he had approached the issue.

“I followed the protocol,” Prince told TMG Digital.

CSA also said they would “launch a further enquiry into this incident and will consider all the related and relevant information in order to arrive at a decision about the strength and the validity of the argument by WCC”, and that, “It is anticipated that the investigation may take up to 14 days.”

That was on October 29 — the 14 days expires on Tuesday.

Asked on Monday night whether CSA had reached a decision, a spokesperson said only, “We will announce the outcome once we have concluded the matter.”

Pressed for a better answer, he became defensive.

The Cobras squad contains four other black Africans — batters Aviwe Mgijima and Simon Khomari, and fast bowlers Akhona Mnyaka and Mthiwekhaya Nabe — while another, spinner Tsepo Ndwandwa, has played for them this season.

None were injured when the game against the Cobras started at Newlands on October 28.

Mgijima has scored just 39 runs in five first-class innings this season while Khomari made two and four in his only match of the campaign.

Mnyaka took 1/30 in the nine overs he bowled on his debut in January, his only first-class match to date.

Nabe also last played for the Cobras in January, and has taken 47 wickets in 31 first-class games at an average of 43.27.

Ndwandwa has claimed three wickets in the two first-class games he has played for the Cobras this season.

In cricket terms, none of those players are banging down the door for a place in the Cobras team.

Who might have been left out to make room for another black African is another consideration.

Five members of the top six who played average more than 30 this summer, with Kyle Verreynne topping the list at 70.66 and Matthew Kleinveldt weighing in at 56.00.

The only merely black — not black African — fast bowler in the side, Dane Paterson, has taken 18 wickets at 21.55 in four games.

The other three members of the team, Zubayr Hamza, George Linde and Dane Piedt, the captain, were all freshly back from South Africa’s poor Test series in India.

It was thus in the national interest that they played. 

And in the Cobras’ interest: before that match they had lost to the Lions and drawn with the Titans and Dolphins.

The game against the Warriors was also drawn, leaving the Cobras second from bottom in the standings.

There was, therefore, no good cricket case to be made for forcing an out-of-form player into a side that needed a win at the expense of someone better equipped for their role.

But, as the Springboks proved emphatically at the men’s World Cup in Japan, quotas can lead to triumph because they open eyes that were previously closed.

There’s a good argument to be made that the Boks would not have done as well as they did had teams not been forced to pick black players.

Decades of selection bias — consciously or not — robbed black players of their opportunities.

With their presence guaranteed, they could not be unfairly sidelined.

And, what do you know, they turned out to be among the best players South Africa had.

That Siya Kolisi, Makazole Mapimpi and Cheslin Kolbe merit their places is beyond question.

As is the likelihood that, without quotas, they would never have been given the chance to prove it.  

It’s a happy ending cricket is still chasing, and the dwindling confidence in CSA’s current leadership won’t bring it any closer. 

Perhaps that vital task should be left to people who know what they’ve doing, like Warriors coach Robin Peterson.

“I can’t comment on what goes on right at the top but I can certainly say there’s great talent in South Africa,” Peterson told TMG Digital during the now controversial Newlands match.

He is about 18 months from completing a Masters in sport directorship at Manchester Metropolitan University.

Peterson hasn’t yet decided what his dissertation topic will be, but he has an idea.

“Maybe I’ll do it on ethical transformation,” he said. “Is there such a thing as ethical transformation?

“I’m living in a situation I can write about, so why not.”

Given South Africa’s past and present, Peterson won’t want for research material.

“It’s very difficult to heal wounds, but if this is your only skill in life it’s very difficult to kill people’s dreams.

“You have to give them opportunities if they’re good enough to play.”

It seems a simple statement, but South Africans will know just how complex it is.

First published by TMG Digital. 

Where the World Cup matters most: on the street

Siya Kolisi lifted the trophy for the umpteenth time, but the fire in his eyes was fresh and the rawness in his roar was real.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

NOT for the first time since November 2, Faf de Klerk flashed his famous underwear at the crowd. Not for the last time, surely, thousands gave raucous approval.

They were gathered on Cape Town’s Grand Parade on Monday, and of a mood to share the Springboks’ joy at winning the men’s World Cup.

De Klerk duly took his place on the stage next to Herschel Jantjies, who offered him a fresh king protea.

A flower? For a regte egte oke from Nelspruit? A Waterkloof alumnus? The skater punk scrumhalf who many feel should have his bloody box kicks, well, boxed and shipped somewhere the sun don’t shine?    

“Nah,” De Klerk seemed to say Jantjies with a mildly disdainful shake of his head.

So Jantjies nipped round De Klerk’s back and quietly tucked the stem of the bloom into the waistband of the blond bliksem’s shorts.

All was revealed when De Klerk turned around, and hoards laughed — not at De Klerk but with him. So did he when he got the joke.

Nothing can go wrong when you’ve won the World Cup.

Even if it did on the last leg of the Boks’ nationwide victory celebration: one of their buses broke down on the N2 after they left the city centre for Langa. Briefly, that is — soon the tour of triumph resumed.

As the convoy oozed away from the City Hall it comprised — besides the must-have swarm of motorcycle outriders — the players’ and their families’ bus, another carrying South African Rugby Union staff, a media bus, three large luxury coaches, two of them emblazoned with the Boks’ “Stronger Together” slogan, five unmarked 4x4s, nine South African police vehicles, a three-car blue-light brigade, seven metro cops cars, and two ambulances.

And yet Damian de Allende was comfortable enough amid the clamour to go barefoot.

Cheslin Kolbe was the prow of the good ship Springbok as it inched away, the William Webb Ellis Cup gleaming goldly from his outstretched arms as the human ocean was parted by barricades just enough to allow the bus passage.

How many were there? Many more than enough to bring emotion shuddering back into the veins of hairy, hardened hacks who thought they had long been irreparably calcified with cynicism.

“Waar’s daai blerrie All Blacks nou,” one man in the mosh pit moving slowly next to the players’ bus asked his fellow celebrant, a reference to some Capetonians’ preference for supporting New Zealand over South Africa as a protest against racism that harks back to apartheid.

You could have had any colour jersey you wanted. As long as it was green and gold.

One man wearing exactly that smuggled himself onto the wrong side of the barricade. He was clearly on a mission, and soon it was revealed.

“Stop corruption,” read the hand-written cardboard sign he held up for a few seconds — before security staff swooped to shoo him back where he belonged.

Two women somewhere in their 50s brought up the rear, waving flags that didn’t exist and dancing to tunes that had yet to be heard when the only people who were allowed to play for the Boks were the same colour they were: white.

People clogged much of every street long before the Boks rolled slowly past them, and when their champions finally arrived they thundered their adulation.

Siya Kolisi, the champion of these champions, has taken his place at the front of the bus to hoist the trophy umpteen times these past few days, but when he did it again coming down Loop Street the fire in his eyes was fresh and the rawness in his roar was real.

The wave rolled over, past and through the usual suspects of life on Cape Town’s streets: the homeless, the addicted, the merely poor. They looked on, still homeless, still addicted, still poor. A World Cup win will not save these souls from the thrust of society’s cold shoulder. 

After the fantastical phalanx had made its way a block or two the road behind it cleared enough to reveal, trying to nose along in the wake of all that, a chicken wholesaler’s truck.

The frown on the driver’s face eased when he saw some tarmac where, moments before, the parade had prevailed.

But only until he looked further ahead to see, barrelling brassily, boisterously, bolshily,  beautifully, even, straight down Darling Street and directly at him and his truck, the West London All Stars minstrel group in full and fabulous flow.

The truck stopped. The driver rested an elbow on the sill of his open window, put a hand under his chin, and waited.

’Cause this is Africa.

First published by Times SELECT.

Desmond and the Springboks do it one more time with feeling

“Good afternoon, molweni, aweh ma se kind.” – Siya Kolisi hits the right note saying hello to Cape Town.

TELFORD VICE in Cape Town

NOTHING can be the same after Desmond Tutu has danced to Leon Schuster’s Hie Kommmie Bokke on the steps of Cape Town City Hall.

And there the best advertisement for religion was on Monday, all 88 years and not many centimetres of him, busting his moves as the statue of Nelson Mandela looked on not knowing quite what to make to it all.

“Hie kommie Bokke …

“Hie kommie Bokke …

“Hoes!

“Bring vir ons die Wêreld Beker!”

Happily, the multitude crammed into the Grand Parade across Darling Street knew what to do: they cheered the Arch to high heaven. 

He had made a dignified exit by the time Early B took the stage to deliver Back die Bokke, and a good thing too.

“Ek is agter in die yard …

“By my bra se spot …

“Nuh!

“Ons geniet ons met ’n tjop and dop …

“Whuh!

“Dinge gaan net af …

“Vrouens kyk na die toddlers …

“En ons almal wag vir die game van die …

“Bokke!”

The rapper, who looks like he spends at least as much time in the gym as Tendai Mtawarira, strutted his stuff with the Springboks themselves lined up behind him.

Clearly, they had heard it all before enough times to have learnt the lyrics. 

Then it was Siya Kolisi’s turn to address the masses.

“Good afternoon, molweni, aweh ma se kind.”

Even the ears on Mandela’s statue would have heard the roar that earned.

“It’s been a tough journey — we’ve been together for 20 weeks — but I think this week has been the most amazing one; coming back and celebrating with you guys.

“Your message has really been amazing.”

Of course, he had a message in return.

“Look how we’re all different — different races, different backgrounds. But we came together for South Africa.

“Just take a look around you. Look how you are making it special for us.

“It’s time for us South Africans to stop fighting, stop arguing and move forward as a country.”

This being the last leg of a celebration that has taken the all singing, all dancing Boks to Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal and the Eastern Cape in the cause of marking their 32-12 triumph over England in the men’s World Cup final in Yokohama on November 2, Kolisi has had plenty of opportunity to practise his prose.

Not that it showed. There was no questioning his sincerity. The man believes his mantra, perhaps because he is his own best example of the magic conjured when it is lived.

Asked earlier at a press conference what the players could do to bottle the joy of the moment and move South Africa’s society forward, Cheslin Kolbe seemed as stunned as if a pass to him had been intercepted.

“Jis; I’m not in the government or anything,” Kolbe said. “I’m just on the field and living my dream.”

But he recovered well enough, and was soon bolting for the tryline.

“Whatever we can do as players we will do to try and put smiles on kids’ and adults’ faces.

“It’s the inches, the little pieces, like that that can really make a big difference in someone’s life.

“And I’m sure that the rest of South Africa, from the president down, they will lay the foundation going forward.

“We have a lot of hope in South Africa, and I’m sure we can get stronger together. That’s what we believe.

“I’m positive for South Africa — I know we will stand together.”

As the Arch might have said, amen to that.

First published by TMG Digital.