Van Niekerk’s fine international career ends in controversy

“My heart breaks for you. You deserve so much better.” – Marizanne Kapp on Dané van Niekerk.

Telford Vice / Cape Town

DANé van Niekerk ended her international career on Thursday, six days after her wife, Marizanne Kapp, hinted on social media that that was imminent. Van Niekerk leaves a skills, experience, leadership, character and personality void and a string of stellar stats, but also controversy over the circumstances that led her to walk away from South Africa’s teams at the age of 29.

Just five players have scored more runs for South Africa in ODIS than Van Niekerk, and only Lizelle Lee has made more in T20Is. Van Niekerk is third among South Africa’s ODI as well as the T20I wicket-takers. She is one of six women’s players worldwide with more than 1,000 runs, 50 wickets and 50 catches in ODIs. She won 29 of her 50 ODIs as captain, and half of her 30 T20Is. She led South Africa to the World Cup semifinal in July 2017 and to the T20 version in March 2020. She played 193 white-ball internationals and one Test in a career that started in March 2009.

But Van Niekerk didn’t play for South Africa after September 2021. She fractured her ankle in a fall at home in January last year, put on weight during her downtime, and was ruled out of the T20 World Cup in February because she failed CSA’s stringently applied fitness test — she was 18 seconds too slow in her two-kilometre run. Her axing divided opinion in the game in South Africa and beyond. In an interview with Cricbuzz’ Purnima Malhotra published on Monday, Van Niekerk admitted that she had succumbed to “20,000 beers and KFC for no particular reason” while she was away from the game. It would have been bittersweet for her that South Africa reached their first senior World Cup final, by a women’s or a men’s team, in her absence: Suné Luus was in charge of the side that went down to Australia by 19 runs at Newlands on February 26.

“We are merely custodians of this sport; I hand it over knowing I have given it my everything and that women’s cricket is in a better place than when I arrived,” Van Niekerk was quoted as saying in a CSA release on Thursday. “That must be the responsibility of the new group, to always make sure you are improving and making a difference. It is time for me to support the new leadership and wish them all the very best. 

“To my amazing family. Thank you for your incredible love and support. From the age of four, you have seen the potential and did everything and anything to help me exceed. I will forever be grateful. 

“My wife, Marizanne, you stood by my side since day one. Thank you for putting up with me and all that came with it, but yet, here you are. You are at the pinnacle of your career and it is my time to support you, the way you have supported me. I love you.”

Van Niekerk is in Royal Challengers Bangalore’s squad but has not played in any of the WPL team’s six games. Kapp has appeared in all six of Delhi Capitals’ matches.

“My heart breaks for you. You deserve so much better,” Kapp posted on social media on Thursday.

Cricbuzz

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Van Niekerk was there, South Africa were not

“We were more focused on the outcome instead of facing the ball.” – Sinalo Jafta

Telford Vice / Newlands

DANé van Niekerk made it beyond the boundary at the T20 World Cup after all. There she was on Newlands’ outfield on Friday, more than an hour before the start of the tournament opener between South Africa and Sri Lanka with the teams’ warm-ups in full flow under the setting sun.

But she was in a skirt. With Hollywood hair. And made-for-TV make-up. Her playing kit would have been 800 kilometres eastward at her home in Kragga Kamma — where she slipped and broke an ankle in January last year to unchain a mournful melody.

If Van Niekerk has spent the past few nights crying herself to sleep at home, who could blame her. Another verse was added to her sad song last month when she was axed from the squad because she had run two kilometres 18 seconds too slow to satisfy CSA’s rigorously applied fitness standards.

Her appearance on Friday was as a television commentator, the same role she had fulfilled during India’s men’s ODI series in South Africa last January. The difference this time was that she wasn’t in a moon boot and on crutches.

So there was nothing to get in the way of her giving Marizanne Kapp, her wife, the biggest of hugs when she emerged from the dugout. There was also nothing to get in the way of the tears. But they had dried by the time Kapp asked Van Niekerk to hold one end of the tape measure while she marked out her run-up at each end. On her way to do so at the Kelvin Grove End, she skipped over some equipment on the ground with a lightness that said at least the ankle was no longer a problem.

Van Niekerk was off the field by the time the anthems were sung. She stood and sang in the broadcasters’ enclosure alongside her former teammate and co-commentator, Mignon du Preez, who exited the game on her own terms in August by retiring. Again, there were tears.

But cricket is, after everything, a show. And shows must go on. This episode was shot through with tension. Veritable sparks flew off the South Africans as they took the field, their anxiety about making a good impression in their first match of a home World Cup palpable. The Lankans went into the game having won only one of their previous six T20Is against South Africa in this country. They had played only one match of any description at Newlands before — a T20I in February 2019, when South Africa won by seven wickets. And when Van Niekerk made an unbeaten 71 off 55.

She also took 3/12 in that game, with Chamari Athapaththu among her victims. Four years on, Athapaththu made a commanding 68 off 50 and shared 86 off 62 with Vishmi Gunaratne in the only stand of the match worth 30 or more. It was also the only time in the game that batting wasn’t made to look like walking backwards and blindfolded across thin ice. That earned Sri Lanka a total of 129/4. 

Athapaththu took three consecutive fours off Nadine de Klerk in the 11th over, and in the 13th Gunaratne did the same to Shabnim Ismail — who is a former No. 1-ranked bowler playing in her 109th T20I. Gunaratne, just 17, has only 10 T20I caps. Her onslaught on Shabnim happened between midpitch conferences with Athapaththu, who played her 107th international in the format. 

“I told her to focus on the ball and to not think about who is bowling,” Athapaththu said of her instructions to her less experienced partner. “She knew Shabnim was the No. 1 bowler. When she whacked the first boundary I said to her, ‘You’ve hit that boundary off the world No. 1 bowler. You can hit another boundary in this over.’ And she did. I said to her, ‘You are very good, better than the world No. 1 bowler. You can hit another boundary.’”

Three moments summed up South Africa’s performance. In the fifth over, Athapaththu came down the pitch to Ayabonga Khaka, had to change her plan when the bowler saw her coming, and nudged to fine leg. Sinalo Jafta and Chloe Tryon, at slip, set off after the ball and hauled it in just before it would have reached the cushions. Tryon did the diving and Jafta the retrieving, and as they ran back to their positions they allowed themselves a terrified high five for a job well done.

With 20 needed off the last dozen deliveries and South Africa six down with Suné Luus and Jafta having made decent starts to their innings, Inoka Ranaweera delivered to South Africa’s captain, who heaved to long-on and set off. But hesitation and confusion saw both batters stranded, then heading for the same end, then hurtling apparently headlessly for safety at either end. Somehow, the Lankans botched the runout chances they had at both sets of stumps. “Great running,” the giant screen read, apparently not ironically. Newlands likes to think it’s special.  

Eight were required off the last ball of the match, and Nonkululeko Mlaba drove Sugandika Kumari high and handsome over extra cover for four. The batters were running, anyway, and after they turned and the awful truth of the home side’s defeat was made real, Khaka sank to her haunches and lowered her head between her knees.

A crowd of 8,402, the biggest ever to watch a women’s game in South Africa, had seen the team almost all of them supported play some of the most skittish cricket imaginable. What had gone so wrong for a side chasing just 130 to win?

“Nerves got in the way, if we’re being honest,” Jafta said. I will commend Cape Town for coming through. The fans were incredible. As an athlete you live for those nerves. We haven’t played in front of such a crowd bar in India.

“We can’t run away from the fact that there are going to be pressure situations. It is a World Cup, and in T20 cricket the margin of error is so slim. We’re focusing on being present. I think that’s what we lacked. We were more focused on the outcome instead of facing the ball.”

Had the presence of Van Niekerk at so important an occasion, and in the wake of her brutal removal from the equation, derailed the South Africans? Kapp, for instance, had seemed unusually upset when she seemed to have pasted Ranaweera for four only to be caught at mid-on. It was a setback, but at 44/2 in the eighth it hardly represented catastrophe.

“As athletes, we’re here to do our job,” Jafta said. “That’s first and foremost, and Marizanne Kapp is probably the most professional person I’ve ever come across. She knows she has her job at hand whether Dané’s here or not. We’re all in a team and everyone supports each other.”

But, for Athapaththu, that wasn’t the whole truth: “No-one accepts that Sri Lanka will win. They think Sri Lanka have average players and are an average side. We don’t have any pressure on us.”

South Africa have exponentially more pressure on them than before Friday’s match. Their next game is against New Zealand in Paarl on Monday. Lose that and they could spend the rest of the tournament as little more than spectators. Them and Van Niekerk.

Cricbuzz

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

This is captain Luus speaking: come on mom and dad

“It’s always difficult being a stand-in captain. You’re one foot in, one foot out.” – Suné Luus

Telford Vice / Cape Town

SUNé Luus will hope her T20 World Cup improves. “My parents have just missed their flight,” South Africa’s captain said on Thursday, the eve of the tournament opener against Sri Lanka at Newlands. “They’d already checked in and had breakfast, and just missed the boarding time. Hopefully they make it for the first game to be here and support me.”

They should. Dozens of flights to Cape Town from Johannesburg, where Cecile and Braam Luus spent more time than planned at the airport, were scheduled for Thursday and Friday, and the match won’t start before 7pm (local time).

But, with a major assignment looming, Luus didn’t need parental problems added to her load. “If you sit down and think about all the things that are happening around you and the amount of pressure and the big occasion, you will put yourself under a lot of pressure and that might not go down so well. So I’m trying to focus on the game tomorrow evening and on cricket, and on my plans and what I need to do to execute and lead the team to victory.”

Among the things that have happened around Luus is the controversial omission of Dané van Niekerk from South Africa’s squad over a failed fitness test. Luus has deputised for Van Niekerk since January, when the regular captain fractured an ankle in a fall at her home.

“It’s always difficult being a stand-in captain,” Luus said. “You’re always one foot in, one foot out. But as I grew up I was always a leader at some stage in whatever team I played for. Leadership qualities came naturally to me. It’s a role I would like to grow into. Every game you play you get more accustomed to your teammates and what they want and need. The older I get the more I understand there’s a lot of work that needs to get done.”

Luus captained provincial under-19 and senior teams before she took charge of South Africa for the first time, in an ODI against India in Potchefstroom in May 2017. By then she had played at international level for almost five years and earned 83 white-ball caps. The South Africans have won 19 of the 34 ODIs they have played under her leadership and 14 of 28 T20Is.

Being appointed captain for the T20 World Cup solidified her position: “It makes my job easier, to take control and stamp my authority on things and how I would like to go about things. It comes with a new dimension. It brings new challenges and difficulties, but it’s a challenge I’m willing to take on and accept and grow in that role.”

How would she assess her captaincy? “I’d like to think I’m very calm and collected on the field. Some people might say I’m too chilled, but in difficult times that’s what a team needs. You don’t want someone who’s frantic and doesn’t know what’s happening. Bringing composure to a team when things aren’t going well is an important quality to have.”

South Africa haven’t hosted a global tournament since the inaugural men’s World T20 in September 2007. They have reached the semi-finals in three of their seven ODI World Cup campaigns and in two of their seven World T20s. They have never been further.  

But that wasn’t all that mattered for Luus: “I don’t think we quite realise what we have already achieved without playing a game. Apart from being successful and winning games, there’s a responsibility for inspiring a nation and inspiring young girls to get out of their comfort zones and to imagine a career where they can do anything. That’s one of our biggest roles as a team.”

Luus’ earliest inspiration had come from her father, a junior cricket coach, who began encouraging her to play when she was a small child. Her news that she would captain South Africa at a World Cup landed like a lump in the throat: “The moment I phoned my dad to tell him he started crying. He was so proud.”

It was not the final call for Cecile and Braam Luus. Happily, there will be more.

Cricbuzz

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Dané’s inferno greets Van Niekerk veto

“The team have pulled together and accept the decision we have made.” — Clinton du Preez, CSA’s women’s selection convenor, on Dané van Niekerk’s axing.

Telford Vice / Cape Town

DANé van Niekerk’s omission on fitness grounds from South Africa’s T20 World Cup squad amounts to self-inflicted sabotage of the home side’s chances of winning their first senior global trophy. You didn’t need to go far to find that view after the selectors announced and defended their decision on Tuesday.

“Absolutely broken,” Van Niekerk posted on social media after she was left out because she had failed to complete a run of two kilometres in nine-and—a-half minutes or less. “One of the best captains in world cricket,” Marizanne Kapp, Van Niekerk’s wife and South Africa’s star allrounder, replied. “You will be missed! The Lord has bigger plans!” Dale Steyn wrote: “Oh fuck, I missed my 2km time by seconds, must mean I’m shit.” Also on social media, Herschelle Gibbs took the opposite view: “You miss it by two or 10 seconds, it’s a fail irrespective of who you are … it’s 2023 not 1990.”

The real-world repercussions have started. Cricbuzz understands Kapp has withdrawn from the T20I series final between South Africa and West Indies in East London on Thursday, and the sudden international retirements of Van Niekerk or Kapp, or indeed both, cannot be ruled out.

Had Van Niekerk made the grade she would have captained South Africa in the T20 World Cup, which will start at Newlands on February 10 with a game between the hosts and Sri Lanka. Instead Suné Luus will lead the side.

It isn’t the first time South Africa’s teams have been affected by CSA’s insistence on the enforcement of fitness and conditioning standards are less stringently observed by cricket authorities in other countries. Lizelle Lee retired from the international arena in July over a failed skin folds test. Sisanda Magala has fallen foul of the rules several times and been punished by omission from the side. He is currently in the ODI squad and showed his value by taking a matchwinning 3/46 against England in Bloemfontein on Friday.

Van Niekerk hasn’t played since September 2021. She fractured an ankle in a fall at her home in January last year, which put her out of the ODI World Cup in New Zealand in March and April. Now mended and prepared, she is fitter than she has been in the past — or before July 2022, when CSA, to keep up with a steadily quickening, more physical global game, raised the height of the fitness hoops players had to jump through to be eligible for selection. 

South Africa have won 15 of their 28 completed T20Is with Van Niekerk as captain. Since she has been injured, they have won just five of 12. From Van Niekerk’s T20I debut in June 2009, only Shabnim Ismail and Kapp have taken more wickets in either format for South Africa. Only Lee has scored more runs in T20Is for South Africa than Van Niekerk. Had the fitness criteria been hiked to where they are now when Van Niekerk’s career was starting, she might never have played for the national teams.

Did CSA understand the effect their decision on Van Niekerk might have on the mental well-being of a squad going into a major tournament? “We considered everything,” Clinton du Preez, CSA’s women’s selection convenor, told a press conference on Tuesday. “We had the discussion around what happens if Dané doesn’t make it; how does that impact. But from a player point of view we’ve created succession in the leadership within the team. The morale of the team is fine. I believe the team have pulled together and that they accept the decision we have made, and that it is required for the good of our players.”

Du Preez made plain that the failed fitness test was all that had deprived South Africa of Van Niekerk’s talent, skill, experience and leadership: “Dané was given an extensive opportunity to meet the minimum criteria, or the fitness benchmark for eligibility into the World Cup. She recently did another fitness test and unfortunately did not meet the minimum criteria, and therefore she’s missed out. It’s purely based on not meeting the fitness criteria that she’s missed out.”

He said a different method to test Van Niekerk’s fitness, believed to involve a treadmill, had been used in addition to normal running: “We’ve tried extensively to assist Dané to get over the line. As a selection panel and a management team we made the commitment that we want to give her the best opportunity to try and get into the squad. Therefore we considered all the other options.”

Van Niekerk’s worth as a player and captain was not in doubt, Du Preez said: “Dané has been an integral part of the team. Her skill-set will always be missed on the field. We’ve had this discussion with her. We’ve extensively reminded her of that, and appreciated the hard work that she’s put in to try to get to the fitness levels.” 

If CSA understood that, why were they rigid about a decreed standard of fitness? “It’s about remaining consistent with our decisions,” Du Preez said. “It’s not something that has been brought about recently. Many other players have gone down this route. We’ve had open discussions about it with everyone. Everyone was quite familiar with the situation and what was required.

“In December we had the discussion with Dané, where we set out clearly what she needs to do and where we expect her to be while acknowledging the improvement she has shown.

“For us as a team, and with the management team to support them, they really want to set the fitness benchmark and ensure all the players meet that. It isn’t anything untoward towards Dané as a cricketer. We treat everyone fairly and we want to remain consistent in our decisions.”

That is the other side of the argument. If all the players who are not Van Niekerk are able to satisfy the stopwatch, why not Van Niekerk? What would it say if allowances were made for favourites? Why should players bother busting a gut when the same degree of measurable gut-busting is not required of everybody?

Some of those players might pose a different question, which could cut both ways: why put in the hard work if some suit can, at the stroke of a pen, undermine an entire squad days before a World Cup?

Cricbuzz

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.