Different dreams on SA’s fields

“You’ve got to give players a sense of belief. There’s talent here, but it’s about how it’s nurtured.” – Paul Adams, Eastern Cape Iinyathi coach 

Telford Vice | Cape Town

“GOOD morning uncle.” Even if you’re of the applicable demographic, it isn’t often you’re greeted so kindly by an official on arrival at a cricket ground. But, in the South African context, Boland Park in Paarl isn’t an ordinary ground.

It has ushers, for a start. They’re all young, all impeccably mannered, and all brown. And they offer warm hellos to visiting strangers, uncle-aged reporters included. This is no accident.

Unlike the country’s other international venues in residential areas, the ground is in the bosom of a district not dominated by whites. Consequently most of those who work there and watch cricket there could live as close as across the road. That’s not the case at other venues, where workers are invariably black or brown and crowds mostly white, and some of the realities of the most unequal society on earth are in your face, whatever colour it is.

Compared to Newlands and the Wanderers, Boland Park is squat and dusty and lacking in facilities. But what it does have is thoroughly utilised and dutifully maintained.

What it doesn’t have is the bilious pomposity that pervades the Cape Town’s concourses and the feral behaviour that stalks the stands in Johannesburg. Paarl’s ground is of its people and their place in the world, and that makes all the difference. Something like togetherness — to call it unity would be too optimistic — is apparent as you pass through the gates. It is a place of excellence — brown excellence, into the bargain — led by the union’s impressive chief executive, James Fortuin. It’s difficult not to believe good things are happening there. Might those good things cross the boundary this season?

If they do, Boland could reach hitherto unscaled heights. They weren’t a force on either side of the racial divide before unity, and thereafter finished in the bottom half of the standings more often than not and stone last four times. In the franchise era they were lumped into the Cobras, whose XIs were dominated by Western Province players.

The six franchises were unbundled before the start of this season, when 15 provincial teams split into divisions of eight and seven will play in the major competitions. Which province goes where was revealed in March by former ICC chief executive David Richardson, who led a four-person committee tasked by CSA with overseeing the bidding process.   

“Boland have a tremendous fan base down in their region, especially among the coloured community,” Richardson said in explaining the decision to award the province first-division status. “They have a true love for cricket; there is a cricket culture in the region. They have a stadium of very good quality, and they are very ambitious when it comes to the development of that stadium. Their development pathways are excellent, and they’ve produced results. They have produced players who contribute to the franchise system and their provincial team has done well consistently over the last four years.”

All good. Now for the hard part: competing. We will start to find out whether Boland will do so on Monday, when they play their first match in the T20 knockout competition that began on Friday. The Bolanders will be up against Eastern Province (EP), who have clung to the title of the franchise they used to be part of, the Warriors. Boland will be known as the Rocks. And thereby hangs a tale.

Bjorn Fortuin, Henry Davids and Ferisco Adams were the only Boland-born players in the Paarl Rocks squad who won the 2019 Mzansi Super League (MSL) with the help of stars like Faf du Plessis and Tabraiz Shamsi. But the crowd took them to heart and, unsurprisingly, the atmosphere at the ground during the tournament outdid even the Highveld’s electrical thunderstorms. Add a successful home final against a Tshwane Spartans outfit that bristled with AB de Villiers and Morné Morkel, and the fairytale wrote itself. The Rocks coach was Adrian Birrell.

“On the back of [the 2019 MSL triumph], they offered me the job,” Birrell told Cricbuzz about his appointment to coach Boland this season. He spoke from Hampshire’s bus as it trundled homeward after Lancashire beat them by a solitary wicket at Aigburth in Liverpool to snuff out the southerners’ hopes of winning the county championship. Five days earlier Birrell’s team had gone down by two wickets to Somerset in the T20 semi-finals. “There’s a lot of pressure to win in England,” he said, adding that he was “exhausted” but also “excited” about the new shape of the game in South Africa.

“Six teams or 66 players [at the top level] is too few; eight teams is a good number,” Birrell said. One of the benefits should be to curb what he called “quite an exodus” of players from the country: “If you look at the associates, you see a hell of a lot of South Africans. Our excellent school system produces too many players for our game. I know this is only two more teams, but it will help.”

The lower levels of international cricket are littered with South Africans: Davy Jacobs in Canada, Gareth Berg in Italy, Roelof van der Merwe in the Netherlands, Dane Piedt in the US, Johann Potgieter in Scotland, and many more. Quotas always come into this conversation, but that is a red herring. Closer to the truth, as Birrell said, is that the engine — the country’s elite schools — produces too much horsepower for the machine it has been assigned to power: the professional game, which is small and impoverished.

Until this season, Boland were minnows even in that pond. Signing Birrell and marquee players like Stiaan van Zyl, Hardus Viljoen, Kyle Abbott and Janneman and Pieter Malan should change that. “The intention is to compete; we’re not there to make up the numbers,” Birrell said.

The opposite is true some 900 kilometres east of Paarl. “The evaluation committee has no doubt as to the potential of the Border cricket region, and its importance to the overall transformation imperative,” Richardson said in March. “Black Africans have played cricket for a long time. They know cricket, they love cricket. A successful Border region is imperative if cricket in South Africa is going to be sustainable in the long run. Unfortunately over the last few years they’ve had issues with governance and administration. Their finances are not strong and their cricket performances are not strong. They are a hotbed of talent and they have contributed players to the franchise system. But I don’t think they’ve fully exploited their potential yet.”

Border — who will be called the Eastern Cape Iinyathi, the isiXhosa word for buffalo — have been consigned to the second division. Former Cobras coach Paul Adams will lead their backroom staff. “It’s a new beginning to bring purpose to the team,” Adams told Cricbuzz. “You’ve got to give them a sense of belief. There’s talent here, but it’s about how it’s nurtured.” 

Compared to the coolly confident Birrell, Adams’ tone was that of a firefighter who reckoned he could bring a damaging blaze under control. 

The Rocks and the Iinyathi play each other in the T20 competition in Kimberley next Tuesday in what could be conjured as a clash of civilisations. Aside from assembling a prominent dressing room, in the past five weeks alone the Rocks have announced sponsorships from an online betting company, a manufacturer of canopies for pick-up trucks, and a jam-maker. The Iinyathi haven’t been heard from since May, when they unveiled Adams as coach.

Buffalo Park in East London, where Border are based, also isn’t ordinary in the South African context. For some, it is a lacklustre ground bookended by a cemetery and a ravine that swarms with lethal snakes, and where a constant howling wind makes lanyards ping against metal flagpoles unrelentingly. For others, particularly cricket’s black players and followers, it is the Mecca where Makhaya Ntini first sprang to national prominence. Thus it is, in its own way, a field of dreams.

Some will see irony in the fact that Birrell — who is steeped in the Eastern Cape, where he was born, raised and schooled and still farms when he isn’t coaching — has migrated across the country while Adams, every inch a Capetonian, has made the journey in the opposite direction. How did Adams end up there? “It’s about where the opportunities are; I must have had about seven interviews to land a role somewhere.”

Better there than at Gauteng, whose Lions were surprise casualties after the opening round of T20 fixtures. Unfancied South Western Districts lost to them but prevailed over Western Province (WP) and the Northern Cape Heat to top pool A. WP downed the Lions by two runs and three other games were decided in the final over. The Lions needed a super over to beat the Heat, who lost all three of their games — perhaps partly because they were clad in black in 30-degree, well, heat. Zubayr Hamza batted with panache for his 63-ball 106 in the opening match, and Hershell America — yes, really — claimed seven wickets at 10.57 in a dozen overs.

With CSA-branded stumps and a naked white rope for a boundary, the unsponsored tournament could be considered another of the suits’ failures. But that would be to disrespect the cricket it has delivered, which has been competitive and, usually, of a decent standard.

That’s the thing about dreams: they can come true on any field. All it takes, as Adams said, is belief.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Freshly fanged Cobras help Titans reach final against Dolphins

Pieter Malan makes highest score in the history of the Cape franchise, who record their biggest win; Aiden Markram evokes Barry Richards.

Telford Vice | Cape Town

TO the Dolphins and the Titans will go the distinction of playing the last match in this era of cricket in South Africa. The teams will clash in the first-class final at Kingsmead on Thursday, ending the domestic season — and bringing the curtain down on the six-team franchise model that has been the country’s highest level of domestic cricket since 2004/05. From next summer South Africa will revert to a 15-team provincial model.

The Dolphins booked their place in the final by beating the Warriors by seven wickets at St George’s Park in the last round of league matches, which ended on Friday. The Titans, who drew with the Lions at the Wanderers, were confirmed as the Dolphins’ opponents by the result of a remarkable game at Newlands.

The Cobras had been fangless for more than two years — they last won a first-class match in January 2019 — but they unsheathed a pair of the sharpest against the Knights, who went into the game having lost only two of their previous six games and as contenders for a place in the final. The visitors’ chances were dented when Nandre Burger and Tshepo Moreki shared eight wickets in the visitors’ first innings of 181. The Cobras batted until before tea on the third day before declaring at 523/8. Pieter Malan’s 264 was his career-best score and the highest in the Cobras’ history. He put on 219 with Zubayr Hamza, who made 86, and 217 with Kyle Verreynne, who scored 109. Kept in the field for 176.3 overs, the Knights lasted only 63.2 overs at the crease. They were dismissed for 127 — their last nine wickets fell for 77 — to seal victory for the Cobras by an innings and 215 runs, the Cape side’s biggest triumph. George Linde, who went wicketless in the first innings, took a career-best 7/29. 

The Dolphins rumbled the Warriors for 124 in Port Elizabeth with Eathan Bosch taking 3/18 and Kerwin Mungroo, Ruan de Swardt and Keshav Maharaj claiming two wickets each. Senuran Muthusamy’s 52, Khaya Zondo’s 111 and Maharaj’s 66 powered the Dolphins’ reply of 358. They lost 5/87 before Zondo and Maharaj added 132 for the eighth wicket. Eddie Moore, who scored 155, and Gihahn Cloete, who made 65, put the Warriors on the path to better things with an opening stand of 145. Then Moore and Yaseen Vallie shared 100 for the second wicket. But the end of that stand, when Maharaj had Vallie stumped, was where it all started going wrong for the home side, who lost their last nine wickets for 100 and were dismissed for 345. Maharaj took 6/93, his third five-wicket haul in two matches and his fourth in five games in the competition this season. The Dolphins needed 112 to win, and Muthusamy scored 57 of them unbeaten.

The Lions and Titans pulled the plug on their match at tea on the fourth day, when the Titans required 164 to win but had already been confirmed as finalists. Dominic Hendricks’ 99 stuck out in the Lions’ first innings of 206. Hendricks’ dismissal was the start of a slide of 6/51. Opener Aiden Markram was eighth out for 100. And a good thing too for the Titans: Sibonelo Makhanya’s 23 was their next best effort in a total of 202 in which Kagiso Rabada took 5/51 and Lutho Sipamla 5/37. Markram’s century was his fifth of the season in this competition, which put him in a club with Peter Kirsten, Graeme Pollock, HD Ackerman, Dean Elgar and Stephen Cook for the most hundreds in a single senior domestic campaign. The Lions found their roar in their second innings, when they declared at 308/9 after Lizaad Williams had taken 4/74. Having ridden high on the swings, Hendricks found himself on the roundabouts when he was caught behind the single he didn’t score in the first innings. But Ryan Rickleton made 58, Reeza Hendricks 96 and Wiaan Mulder 56 not out to keep the Lions in the hunt. Set 313 to win, the Titans looked up for it while Elgar and Markram were scoring 68 and 64 and sharing 125. They equalled the record for the most century opening stands in senior domestic cricket in South Africa — in 1998/99, Sven Koenig and Adam Bacher also mounted four such partnerships. Markram’s aggregate of 945 runs for the season, at an average of 94.50, left him 55 short of emulating Barry Richards, who topped 1,000 runs in a domestic season in 1971/72 and 1972/73. But Richards had 15 and 16 innings during those summers, compared to Markram’s dozen trips to the crease in 2020/21.

On Thursday the Dolphins will try to clear the last hurdle of a campaign for the only time in three attempts in 2020/21. But it’s the first time this summer that the Lions have not reached a final. Those teams shared the one-day title after that decider was washed out, and the Lions beat the Dolphins in the T20 final.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Maharaj tames Lions with bat and ball

Double centuries for Markram and Verreynne.

Telford Vice | Cape Town

KESHAV Maharaj batted and bowled the Dolphins to victory over the Lions at the Wanderers in the latest round of franchise first-class matches in South Africa, which ended on Wednesday. Despite a double century by Aiden Markram, the Titans and Knights couldn’t find a way past each other in Centurion. At Newlands, not even the season’s biggest total and the highest individual score of the summer, by Kyle Verreynne, could help the Cobras end a run of more than two years without a victory.

The Knights top pool A with one round of matches remaining but the Dolphins are only 1.16 points behind. The defending champions, the Lions, are 28.98 points off the pace. The Titans are 14.16 points ahead of the Warriors in pool B with the Cobras a further 10.32 adrift. The final, which will be contested by the pool winners, is scheduled for five days from March 25.

The Dolphins slipped to 162/5 before Khaya Zondo and Eathan Bosch added 119. Once they were separated the wickets resumed falling: the last five went down for 94. Beuran Hendricks and Lutho Sipamla shared six of them in a total of 375, in which Bosch scored his first century, 104 off 127 balls. The Lions replied with 362, and they would have been far more than 13 runs behind without opener Ryan Rickelton, who was last out for 194 — his sixth first-class century but his first at franchise level. Reeza Hendricks made 52 in a second-wicket stand of 134 and Lutho Sipamla was part of a ninth-wicket effort of 63. But between those peaks the Lions lost 7/99. Maharaj bowled more than a third of the overs in the innings and took 6/126.

The Dolphins let the advantage slip when they shambled to 113/6 with Marques Ackerman and Zondo suffering first-ballers and only Keegan Petersen standing firm. Then Maharaj joined the latter to add 79. Petersen scored 56 off 77 and Maharaj made 89 off 62 — hitting 62 in fours and sixes — to boost the visitors to a total of 235 in which Wiaan Mulder took 4/37. That left the Lions a gettable target of 249, but Daryn Dupavillon bowled Dominic Hendricks without a run on the board and Maharaj, who came on at first change, removed Rassie van der Dussen second ball. The Lions crashed to 90/5 on their way to being dismissed for 162 in 53 overs, which made the Dolphins winners by 86 runs. Maharaj took 7/48 to complete a match haul of 13/174.

Migael Pretorius and Mbulelo Budaza took seven wickets between them to dismiss the Titans for 263 on the first day. Neil Brand’s 107 and Grant Thompson’s 52 shone from a scorecard in which the last six wickets fell for 24. The Knights earned a lead of 151 when they declared at 414/9 with Farhaan Behardien making 142 amid half-centuries by Raynard van Tonder, Patrick Kruger and Shaun von Berg. Behardien shared 106 with Van Tonder and 113 with Kruger. Lizaad Williams plugged away for 30 overs for his 4/103.

Dean Elgar and Markram batted together for 55 overs at the top of the order in the Titans’ second innings on Tuesday and for another 13.4 overs on Wednesday before Von Berg had Elgar caught behind for 90 to end the stand at 213. In his next over Von Berg caught and bowled Brand for a duck. But thoughts of the Knights riding away with the match receded as Sibonelo Makhanya, who scored 68, helped Markram put on 141. Markram was still there when elbows were bumped on the draw. He scored 204 not out, his first double century.       

The Cobras overcame losing openers Pieter Malan and Jonathan Bird with 15 runs scored to pile up 513/6 before they declared as stumps loomed on the second day. The total was built on Verreynne’s undefeated and career-best 216, 118 of them claimed in boundaries. Verreynne put on 108 with Tony de Zorzi, who scored 68, another 192 with George Linde, who made 107, and 122 with Imran Manack, whose unbeaten 55 was his best effort at this level. The Warriors used nine bowlers to send down 144 overs, but none of them could take more than two wickets. By the close on the third day the visitors had been reduced to 259/9 with Ayabulela Gqamane and Marco Jansen, numbers eight and nine, scoring half-centuries and Tshepo Moreki and Akhona Mnyaka taking three wickets each. The Warriors needed another 104 runs to avoid being told to follow on, but rain began falling on the third evening and continued until the match was called off just before noon on Wednesday. The Cobras have now gone 15 first-class games without winning.

First published by Cricbuzz. 

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

New old world looms for domestic game

“If your franchise came sixth did it really matter? There was no real consequence. In promotion and relegation there is huge consequence.” – David Richardson on a key aspect of the new structure.

Telford Vice | Cape Town

IF you turned on a television on Sunday and subscribe to the service offered by one of sport’s leading broadcasters, you might have seen something that hadn’t appeared on that platform for almost 15 years. There, live and in living colour on a dazzling Highveld morning, was a South African first-class match.

The coverage in the four-day game between the Titans and the Knights lasted until stumps, and will do until the match is over. SuperSport will also broadcast a game in the last round of the competition, which starts next Tuesday, and the five-day final, which begins on March 25. Banal as those facts will seem, they are extraordinary.

Last time first-class cricket was broadcast live and ball-by-ball in this country Charl Langeveldt had played less than half of his 87 matches for South Africa. He is now their bowling coach. We were days away from Jason Gillespie’s Test double century, Brian Lara’s third appointment as West Indies captain, and the ICC awarding the 2011 and 2015 World Cups to Asia and Antipodea.

It was April 2006, when the Dolphins and the Titans shared the title after somnambulating to a draw in the final at Kingsmead. With that cricket played in whites in South Africa, when it didn’t involve a Test team, disappeared from television. All the while the Lions and the Warriors, et al, have played plenty of one-day and T20 cricket onscreen. But the first-class aspect of the franchise revolution, which hit South Africa in 2004-05 when 11 provincial teams were melded into six newly minted sides with unfamiliar names dreamt up by marketing types, has barely been televised. Thirteen provincial teams have continued to exist, but essentially as feeders for the franchises, which were established through amalgamation. Geographical neighbours Western Province, Boland and South Western Districts formed the Cobras, for instance.         

But from the summer of 2021-22 the franchises will be disbanded and the top level of domestic cricket in South Africa will revert to a provincial model. Boland, Eastern Province, Free State, Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal, North West, Northerns and Western Province will play in the first division. The second division will be contested by South Western Districts, Easterns, Border, KwaZulu-Natal Inland, Northern Cape, Limpopo and Mpumalanga. That won’t change for two seasons. After the 2023-24 campaign the bottom team in the first division will be relegated and the winner of the second division promoted.

The intention of folding 11 teams into six was to narrow the pipeline to the national team, so only the best players would reach the highest level. That argument prevailed over the theory that the game in the country was too big to limit elite playing opportunities to 66. Now it seems the thinking has swung towards broadening the stage to ensure quality talent gets more chances to shine.

It is counterintuitive, then, that the new deal means there will be 75 fewer player contracts on offer. Currently 280 players are signed to franchises. In future the eight first-division outfits will contract 16 players each and the seven second-tier sides 11. That adds up to 205. Jobs will also diminish in the coaching sector, with franchise coaches likely to be put in charge of the major province in their region, thus pushing out some of their provincial counterparts. Administration and other staff around the country could suffer the same fate.

How did we get here? Through a process CSA started in 2016, ostensibly as a way to cut costs. South Africa’s struggling economy has left a smaller slice of the cake for sport than previously. And cricket’s share is crumbling, given its perennial governance problems that have alienated sponsors. With the franchises leaning ever heavily on CSA for financial survival, push has come to shove.

“In the long run we definitely expect the process to save CSA money,” Pholetsi Moseki, CSA’s acting chief executive, told an online press conference on Monday. “More than that we hope that it will allow the affiliates to commercialise themselves better and chase opportunities in the market.” The parents are trying to get the kids to stand on their own two feet. Less kindly, they are kicking them out of the house.

The South African Cricketers’ Association (SACA), which represents the players, necessarily took a different view, as articulated by chief executive Andrew Breetzke: “The Proteas men’s team generates over 80% of CSA revenue. We need to be competing at the highest level, we need to be at the table with the big three, and therefore we need a strong team.” That meant domestic cricket would have to be as healthy as possible. “We need our top players playing, they must be playing in competitive cricket, and the step up to international cricket must be as close as possible. Within that domestic structure we need a strong transformation pipeline. Our teams must represent the demographics of South Africa.” He spoke of the imperative for CSA to be “financially viable and sustainable”, adding ominously: “We have a consistent fear about the financial sustainability of cricket in South Africa and in the world at the moment, for that matter.”

CSA resolved in 2016 to redesign the domestic game, and the last few months have involved deciding who would be in which division. Provinces subjected themselves to a bidding process that was presided over by a four-person committee led by David Richardson, the former South Africa Test wicketkeeper and ICC chief executive. The committee used a scorecard devised by CSA management in consultation with the provinces.

“The committee’s role was to make sure that all the data that was used to populate that portion of the scorecard which evaluated the historical performance and current status of the members across the seven key dimensions was correctly captured and the weightings correctly applied,” Richardson said. “Secondly, the role was to evaluate the future strategies and plans of the members against those seven key dimensions.

“Those dimensions are cricket services and their infrastructure — what are the pathways for developing not only players but also coaches and umpires? What is the structure around the professional team performances; the high performance area? What does their stadium look like? What does their secondary field look like? On the commercial and financial side, what do the revenues look like for the future? What are the commercial plans? What kind of support do they have from other stakeholders such as local government? We also looked at the important dimension of transformation, and how they are structured from a governance and administration point of view, and the finances of each of the members.”

First-division provinces were expected to be “financially self-sustainable, well-structured and administered, producing results on the field, and providing access and quality opportunities for all who play the game”. 

The difference between first and second-division realities is best illustrated by the contrasting fates of Boland and Border. Both are among cricket’s smaller provinces, and both are important in transformation terms. Boland are based in Paarl, where cricket is central to the community, most of whom self-identify as coloured. Outside of South Africa they would be regarded as brown or mixed race. Border are based in East London, which is a hub for many towns and villages where the history of black cricket stretches back more than a century.

But while Boland has thrived through excellent management, headed by chief executive James Fortuin, Border is mired in ethical and financial problems that have spilled onto the field — they were dismissed for 16 by KwaZulu-Natal in a first-class match last week.

“Boland have a tremendous fan base down in their region, especially among the coloured community,” Richardson said. “They have a true love for cricket; there is a cricket culture in the region. They have a stadium of very good quality, and they are very ambitious when it comes to the development of that stadium. Their development pathways are excellent, and they’ve produced results. They have produced players who contribute to the franchise system and their provincial team has done well consistently over the last four years.”

He painted a different picture about Border: “The evaluation committee has no doubt as to the potential of the Border cricket region, and its importance to the overall transformation imperative. Black Africans have played cricket for a long time. They know cricket, they love cricket. A successful Border region is imperative if cricket in South Africa is going to be sustainable in the long run. Unfortunately over the last few years they’ve had issues with governance and administration. Their finances are not strong and their cricket performances are not strong. They are a hotbed of talent and they have contributed players to the franchise system. But I don’t think they’ve fully exploited their potential as yet.” 

In some ways not much will change. The provinces in which the franchises are headquartered — Eastern Province, Free State, Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal, Northerns and Western Province — have all earned places in the first division. Effectively, the Knights will become Free State and slough off Northern Cape, their little brother whose players rarely reached the franchise XI. But the new system will be stress tested if bigger provinces, with their cash and cachet, are relegated.

“One of the challenges with the franchise system is that [franchises] went through cycles and stages,” Richardson said. “If you came sixth did it really matter? There was no real consequence. In promotion and relegation there is huge consequence. When you get demoted you have the potential of losing sponsors and financial support.”

That could happen in Cape Town, where it’s not impossible that Newlands’ majesty will be sullied by Western Province slipping down the ranks. The Cobras last won a first-class match in January 2019. They’ve gone three seasons without winning more than half their list A games, and they lost four of their five matches in this summer’s T20 competition. You’re not going to turn on your television to watch that, even if Table Mountain is in the background. 

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Knights, Warriors win, Migael Pretorius heads for Centurion

Raynard van Tonder’s 200 was his sixth century in 58 first-class innings, his fourth score of 150 or more, and his third double century.

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

WHEN the latest round of first-class matches in South Africa started on Sunday, Migael Pretorius might not have been thinking too far beyond the next four days. When the round ended on Wednesday, he was probably trying not to think about making his Test debut against Sri Lanka at Centurion on December 26.

Fast bowler Pretorius was added to South Africa’s ranks on Wednesday in the absence of Kagiso Rabada, the victim of a lingering groin strain who CSA say has “not yet been medically cleared” to play in the Test series. With Lungi Ngidi, Anrich Nortjé, Beuran Hendricks and Glenton Stuurman also in the squad, Pretorius looks unlikely to crack the nod even if South Africa field an all-pace attack. But, having taken 20 wickets at 20.65 in five first-class matches this season, he has earned recognition.

Pretorius didn’t have too much to do with the Knights beating the Lions by nine wickets in Bloemfontein on Wednesday: he took 3/102 in the match. The tone of the contest was set in its opening hour, when Raynard van Tonder walked to the crease at the fall of the Knights’ first wicket. When he was dismissed more than seven-and-a-half hours of playing time later, Van Tonder had scored 200 — his sixth century in 58 first-class innings, his fourth score of 150 or more, and his third double century. Van Tonder hit 112 of his runs in fours and sixes, no mean feat on South Africa’s biggest ground in area terms.

But Ferisco Adams’ 96 was the Knights’ only other effort of more than 30 in a total of 472 in which the biggest partnership was the 111 shared by Van Tonder and Shaun von Berg, who faced 83 balls for his gritty 21. Leg spinner Von Berg increased his share of the spotlight by taking 5/93 in the Lions’ reply of 262, which would have been significantly smaller had Rassie van der Dussen not stood firm for an unbeaten 107. 

The Lions followed on 210 runs behind, and this time opener Dominic Hendricks kept their heads above water until he was last out for 98. But, with Von Berg sharing the new ball and taking 4/68 — completing a match haul of 9/161 — left-arm fast bowler Duan Jansen claiming 4/44 on his franchise debut, and the visitors losing their last eight wickets for 85 runs, the Knights needed only 18 to win. They got there in six overs.

The Warriors beat the Cobras by 80 runs at St George’s Park despite the visitors taking a lead of 61 into the second innings. That happened because the Warriors crashed to 194 all out in two sessions with Rudi Second’s 55 — all but nine of them in boundaries — their only highlight and George Linde taking 4/52. Kyle Verreynne hit 80 of his 97 in fours to help the Cobras reply with 255. Marco Jansen and Jon-Jon Smuts took three wickets each.

There were more runs left in Second’s bat, 114 of them, and Yaseen Vallie’s 57 — and the 167 they put on for the third wicket — seemed to have established the Warriors’ dominance. But Vallie and Second were dismissed by consecutive deliveries, the start of a slide that would net eight wickets for 90 runs with Calvin Savage taking 4/81. The Cobras chased 265 to win but were dismissed for 184 with Smuts snapping up 3/47. Opener Janneman Malan, who scored 65, was the only Cobras batter to reach 20.

The other match of the round, between the Titans and the Dolphins at Centurion, was called off after the first day because one of the Dolphins’ players was confirmed to have contracted Covid-19. By then, Aiden Markram and Dean Elgar had scored half-centuries in the Titans’ first innings of 269/9, and Ruan de Swardt and Keshav Maharaj had taken 4/41 and 3/48.

Negative tests for Covid permitting, Markram and Elgar will open the batting for South Africa against Sri Lanka, while Maharaj is the only specialist spinner in the squad. Ngidi, Sarel Erwee and Keegan Petersen, who were involved in the match but didn’t get the chance to show what form they’re in, are also in the mix for the Test series.

Of the other players in the Test squad whose performances aren’t mentioned above, Beuran Hendricks took 1/77, Wiaan Mulder scored 26 and claimed 2/68, and Stuurman took 4/101 and made 30. CSA said Quinton de Kock and Anrich Nortjé were rested for this week’s matches while Faf du Plessis was granted time off to be with his family before South Africa’s busy summer resumes.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Another dud for Elgar, another ton for Markram

The Warriors’ 436 is the highest fourth innings in SA franchise first-class history, but they lost.

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

NOT long ago, death, taxes and Dean Elgar opening the batting for South Africa’s Test team were life’s unshakeable certainties. Perhaps it’s time to revisit that truth. Death and taxes remain with us, but, reassuringly, Elgar is proving himself human.

Elgar was dismissed for nine in his only innings for the Titans in their drawn match against the Cobras at Centurion, which ended on Thursday. That followed Elgar’s efforts of 20 and six in the previous round of the four-day competition, which came after he made 66 and nought, and 101 and 58.

So there is no question that he will be in the XI — perhaps even as captain — when South Africa take on Sri Lanka at Centurion on December 26 in the first of two Tests. But, to make the most of that opportunity, he will want to return to big runs when the Titans host the Dolphins on December 13.

Elgar’s opening partner for the Centurion-based side won’t be as anxious. Aiden Markram scored 113 against the Cobras to complete a hattrick of hundreds — he made 149 and 121 against the Warriors last week. The last player to take guard at the top of the Test order with Elgar, Pieter Malan, made 125 for the Cobras. Victor Mpitsang, South Africa’s convenor of selectors, should ensure he has enough headache remedies to hand.

Neil Brand made 115 in a stand of 178 with Markram, and Calvin Savage’s 5/77 was the only five-wicket haul claimed in a match that was called off at tea on the fourth day. The Cobras were 236 ahead with five wickets in hand in the third innings.

At St George’s Park, the Warriors fell 76 runs short of hauling in a mammoth target of 513. Rudi Second kept the home side in the game with his 171, but, having reached 291/5, they lost their last five wickets for 145 runs with Sisanda Magala and Delano Potgieter sharing six.

Ryan Rickleton, Wesley Marshall and Wiaan Mulder stood firm for the Lions in the first innings with their scores of 72, 145 and 91. No-one else reached 30 in an innings of 389 in which Basheer Walters took 5/61. The Warriors were shot out for 118 inside 48 overs in reply, with Magala’s 3/37 leading the attack.

Rickleton made 59 and Mulder a 109-ball 100 not out before the Lions declared their second innings closed and the Warriors set about their unlikely chase, which was ended before tea on Thursday. It won’t make the home side feel better that their total of 436 was the highest for the fourth innings in South African franchise history.

The best bowling of the round was seen at Kingsmead, where Daryn Dupavilion took 7/38 and 4/66: match figures of 11/104. That condemned the Knights to totals of 116 — after they chose to bat first, no less — and 213, and helped the Dolphins win by five wickets. The Dolphins weren’t convincing themselves in a first innings of 253 in which Grant Roelofsen’s 73 shone out. Chasing only 77 to win, they crashed to 62/5 in the second dig with Shaun von Berg striking twice in an over before Keegan Petersen and Mangaliso Mosehle took them home.

After four rounds, the Titans are clear frontrunners in Pool A, where they have a lead of 25.38 points over the Cobras, who are 1.2 ahead of the Warriors. But only 3.52 separates the Dolphins, Lions and Knights, in that order, in Pool B.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

All for Markram, none for De Bruyn

First win for the Lions, Cobras the only team without a win after three rounds.

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

AIDEN Markram and Theunis de Bruyn had the most contrasting experiences possible for the Titans against the Warriors in franchise first-class matches this week.

Sisanda Magala claimed the only five-wicket haul of the round for the Lions, whose victory over the Knights was sealed by a record stand by Joshua Richards and Dominic Hendricks.

Khaya Zondo scored a century for the Dolphins in their draw against the Cobras, which is now the only winless team in the competition. 

Opener Markram scored 149 and 121 in Centurion, marking the first time in his first-class career of 69 matches that he has made centuries in both innings. He was the only Titans player to reach 50 in totals of 320 and 289. Teammate De Bruyn, who batted at Nos. 3 and 4, suffered his first pair in his 71st first-class game. Marco Jansen took match figures of 7/135 for the Warriors.  

Yaseen Vallie’s 80, Sinethemba Qeshile’s 97 and half-centuries by Matthew Breetzke and Lesiba Ngoepe earned the Warriors a first-innings lead of 72. It chased 218 to win, and got there with three wickets standing thanks to Vallie’s 55 and sturdy 30s by Rudi Second and Ngoepe.

At the Wanderers, Magala took 6/60 in the Knights’ first innings of 300, in which no other bowler claimed more than two wickets. The Lions crashed to 47/5 in reply and were dismissed 98 runs behind with Mbulelo Budaza, Migael Pretorius and Gerald Coetzee sharing eight wickets.

Wiaan Mulder and Delano Potgieter claimed seven wickets between them in the Knights’ second innings of 235. That set the Lions a sizeable target of 334, which Richards and Hendricks — who scored nought and six in the first innings — whittled down patiently in their opening partnership of 256. Richards’ 136 was his first franchise century, and the partnership is the biggest for the first wicket for the Lions. The previous record, 226 by Stephen Cook and Reeza Hendricks against the Cobras in 2017/18, was set in Potchefstroom, a featherbed compared to the Wanderers’ lively surface. The Lions lost 4/33 after the openers were dismissed, but won by four wickets. 

The Dolphins declared in both innings at Kingsmead, where Zondo made 105, Senuran Muthusamy 79 and Marques Ackerman 66 for the home side before the Cobras were dismissed 77 behind — Tony de Zorzi made 58 — with Muthusamy taking 4/58. Scores of 56 by each member of the Dolphins’ top order, Sarel Erwee, Muthusamy and Keegan Petersen, built the lead to 294 when the declaration came. The Cobras had slipped to 155/6 — key batter Zubayr Hamza fell first ball — when the draw was agreed. Muthusamy completed a solid allround performance by taking 4/56, giving him match figures of 8/114. 

The Titans and the Knights have now won two matches each, while the Lions celebrated success for the first time. The Warriors is the only side to have lost two games, and the Cobras the only team with two draws.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Has Shamsi turned into a Test spinner?

8/32 the best figures by a slow bowler in South Africa in 25 years.

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

IT’S too soon to say Tabraiz Shamsi should replace Keshav Maharaj in South Africa’s Test team, but the left-arm wrist spinner did his cause no harm at St George’s Park this week.

Shamsi, who has played 44 white-ball internationals but only two Tests, took 8/32 for the Titans in the second innings of their match against the Warriors. Maharaj, South Africa’s first-choice Test spinner since 2016, claimed match figures of 3/187 for the Dolphins against the Knights in Bloemfontein.

Both matches were played on slow surfaces that took turn, but neither will be used in the Test series against Sri Lanka — which will be played at Centurion and the Wanderers from December 26. Those are the fastest pitches in the country, and spin is likely to be little more than an afterthought.

So Beuran Hendricks’ career-best 7/29 in the first innings for the Lions against the Cobras in Johannesburg, and the 3/56 he took in the second dig to complete match figures of 10/85, could be his ticket to more Test caps. 

Shamsi’s haul bettered Dale Steyn’s 8/41 against the Eagles — the Knights former name — in Bloem in December 2007 as the best performance by any bowler in an innings for the Titans. Not since Stephen Peall took 9/76 for a Zimbabwe Board XI against Boland B in Paarl in October 1995 has a spinner returned better innings figures in a first-class match South Africa.

Unsurprisingly, Shamsi stood out in a match in which no-one made a century — Dean Elgar scored 66 and Heinrich Klaasen 68 among four half-centuries — and no other bowler took more than four wickets in an innings. The Warriors were dismissed for 124 in their second innings and the Titans knocked off their target of 63 in nine overs to win by eight wickets.

Back in Bloem, Raynard van Tonder’s 166 took the Knights to a first innings total of 424. Migael Pretorius, who made his career-best score of 62 in that innings, and Alfred Mothoa shared seven wickets to dismiss the Dolphins for 162, and a century stand for the Knights between Pite von Biljon and Farhaan Behardien, who scored 93 and 50, set the visitors a target of 471. They were bowled out for 243 with Pretorius taking 4/52 to complete a match haul of 7/102.

With Hendricks on fire at the Wanderers, the Cobras were shot out for 115, of which Kyle Verreyne scored 55 off 66 balls. Opener Dominic Hendricks was ninth out for 130 in the Lions’ reply of 324, a difference of 209 runs. The Cobras crashed to 22/3 in their second innings before Tony de Zorzi and Verreyne steadied them with a partnership of 136 and scores of 67 and 72. But they were both dismissed before George Linde took guard at 167/5 to score an unbeaten 69. That, and Nandré Burger’s 38 not out, helped the Cobras take the lead and stay at the crease until elbows were bumped on the draw.

Thursday’s results mean the Titans and the Knights have won both their fixtures while the Dolphins have slipped to their first loss. The Warriors have gone down twice, and the Cobras have lost and drawn.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

Plenty to ponder as runs, wickets, results flow

Dean Elgar and Keshav Maharaj bank the best performances among the Test captain candidates.

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

POSITIVE results all round, two big centuries, three other mere hundreds, a triple-century stand, two-five wickets hauls, and an intriguing sub-plot starring the contenders for the Test captaincy. South Africans hoping the season’s opening round of first-class fixtures would be eventful enough to take their minds off the wider state of cricket in their country couldn’t have asked for more.

All three matches reached the fourth day on Thursday, with the Knights becoming the first team to wrap up victory, by 179 runs, over the Warriors in Bloemfontein. At Kingsmead the Dolphins were nine-wicket winners over the Lions. The Titans nipped home by two wickets against the Cobras at Newlands.

Sarel Erwee scored 199 and Keegan Petersen 173 in the Dolphins’ first innings. They put on 337 for the second wicket after the first fell to the third ball of the innings. Keshav Maharaj shared the new ball in the Lions’ second innings and took 6/101.

Gerrit Snyman’s 78-ball 109 was the standout feature of the game in Bloem. It marked the first time a player had reached a century before lunch on the opening day in a domestic first-class match in South Africa since 1978.

Only four completed totals in first-class cricket history worldwide to include a century have been lower than the Titans’ first innings effort of 150. The centurion was Dean Elgar, who made 101. George Linde claimed 5/65 to help the Cobras take a lead of 114 into the second innings. Tabraiz Shamsi’s 4/79 and tight bowling by all — part-timer Aiden Markram’s seven overs cost only 10 runs — kept the Titans’ target to 316, which they passed after lunch with Theunis de Bruyn seventh out for 127. Elgar scored 58 and Linde’s 4/123 gave him match figures of 9/188.

At least until the second round starts on Monday, Linde, Shamsi and Maharaj — spinners all and all left-armers, though a mix of orthodox and un — are the top wicket-takers in a country where fast bowlers rule.  

The needle match of the round was at Newlands, not least because the visitors’ coach, Mandla Mashimbyi, had joked that the Cobras amounted to a “Titans B team”. Four members of the home side’s XI were previously attached to the Titans or their feeder province, Northerns. The result means the Cobras, the only team not to win a match in this competition last season, have gone 10 first-class games without victory.

Elgar and Maharaj have both declared their ambition to succeed Faf du Plessis as Test captain. Another candidate, Markram, made up for treading on his wicket in the first innings — when he scored two — with an assured 48 in the second dig. Temba Bavuma, who is also in the leadership mix, scored 43 and 25 for the Lions. Still another, Rassie van der Dussen, made one and 10, also for the Lions.

Elgar restated his case for the captaincy with characteristic forthrightness in an exclusive interview this week with Cricket Fanatics, a Cape Town-based online magazine: “Without sounding arrogant or pig-headed, I think it would make the one logic sense [sic] in Cricket South Africa at the moment. In saying that, that’s out of your control as a player. I do feel it’s a position I’ve really tried to groom myself for, from a personal point of view. But it’s totally out of my powers. There are other people who make those decisions, and rightly so. You’ve got to respect whichever way they want to go.”

One of those people is Victor Mpitsang, the new convenor of selectors, who ended his career with the Knights as Elgar’s was starting: they were in the same XI for the franchise in four first-class matches in 2010-11. The other party in picking the new captain is Graeme Smith, the director of cricket, who opened the batting with Elgar in both innings of one of the nine Tests they played together.

Sharing a dressingroom with the famously feisty Elgar can be challenging — little stops him from speaking his mind. But by all accounts he, Mpitsang and Smith have remained on good terms. None of the other captaincy hopefuls have direct ties to the people who matter in this process.

Advantage Elgar? We will know in the coming weeks: the Test series against Sri Lanka starts on December 26.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

New board pledges improvement but CSA drops ball on first-class coverage

How far removed are South Africa’s administrators from the most important people in the game, the fans, if they treat them as if they don’t exist?

TELFORD VICE | Cape Town

CSA’s new interim board has gone onto the front foot to promise a better game for all. The structure, named by government on Friday in the wake of the elected board members finally heeding multiple calls for their resignations, met on Monday even as further evidence that cricket’s suits are out of touch with their core constituency raged around the country.

With the pandemic having derailed the game globally, the start of the domestic season on Monday was CSA’s perfect opportunity to give cricketminded South Africans reasons to be cheerful. In the opening round of first-class fixtures, the Cobras are playing the Titans at Newlands, the Dolphins are up against the Lions at Kingsmead, and the Knights are at home to the Warriors in Bloemfontein.

The game’s problems in South Africa are many. But at least — after months of uncertainty during which the only story in town was chronic and deepening administrative ineptness on every front — there was cricket, lovely cricket. Four-day games are no longer broadcast live on television in South Africa and spectators couldn’t go and watch because of Covid-19 regulations, but the public would be significantly comforted by the fact that the players were back on the field. They would also have something else to think, talk and post about than CSA’s multiple failings. Whatever could go wrong …

Given the circumstances you might have thought CSA would have done all they could to ensure everyone and anyone who was interested in the matches knew how to access coverage, if only to drown the drip of negativity in four days of rare positive sunshine. Instead, they did the opposite. South Africans accustomed to logging on to live ball-by-ball scoring on a range of well-known online platforms — including Cricbuzz — found that the flow of information on most sites had slowed to a trickle of intermittent updates. The details were still available elsewhere, but at a level nowhere near as detailed as previously and not where many fans go for information.

Why? Because a new data contractor has been enlisted, which has taken live coverage of domestic cricket away from the usual online places. That is CSA’s right: it owns the content of the cricket played under its auspices, and fans should not expect something for nothing. Even or perhaps especially in these days of widespread economic strife. But to not shout that new reality from the rooftops to forewarn the public — and tell them where they could still get their fix, albeit at a lower quality — is an indictment. How far removed are South Africa’s administrators from the most important people in the game, the fans, if they treat them as if they don’t exist?

“The board specifically noted the dissatisfaction expressed by many journalists and cricket fans regarding the four-day matches, which had commenced, but were not being broadcast live,” a release on Tuesday said. CSA couldn’t get even that right. Earth to the suits: be less concerned with your deservedly dismal standing in the press and concentrate on improving your standing with the public, who are exponentially more important than the press. The press represent the fans. Do right by the fans and your standing in the press will improve. Apologies, readers, for the clunky repetition, but it seems we are dealing with people who have no clue of how these things work.

The release noted that the board met “to address a host of matters … but also to emphasise that its main objective is to restore public confidence in the game of cricket amongst all its stakeholders, particularly the players, media and the cricket-loving public”. You would be forgiven for surmising it’s not for nothing that the public are last on that list.

Having made that assumption, where might you lodge a complaint? Good luck figuring out who’s in charge given this kind of murky explanation, as per the release: “In terms of the current MOI [memorandum of incorporation], CSA’s members council is the highest decision-making authority in South African cricket. The board therefore accounts to the members council. However, the board clarified the lines of authority between itself, the members council, and executive management. The board is responsible for all operational matters within CSA, with the executive management reporting directly to the board and not the members council.” So, is the board in charge? Or the members council? Maybe DRS could tell us.

There was greater clarity on the board’s approach to dealing with the Fundudzi report. Its 468 pages detail CSA’s problems between 2016 and 2019 and which in August was used to fire Thabang Moroe as chief executive. The release said board members Zak Yacoob, Dawn Mbatha, Judith February and Caroline Mampuru had been “tasked … to assess the implications of the report and the action which needs to be taken” and to “discuss making the report public”. Note that all the members of the sub-committee do not come from cricket structures: a good thing. “We will do everything possible to ensure that those responsible for misdeeds and bringing the game and the organisation into disrepute are held to account,” February was quoted as saying.

According to the release, “The board is of the view that one of its members ought to represent South Africa at the ICC.” Another worthwhile idea.

Amid the missteps, then, there is the promise of improvement. But that’s all it is: a promise. The interim board should be under no illusion that, by stepping into this arena, it will be seen as nothing better than the problems it has come to confront until it finds and implements solutions. It should start by putting the public first.

First published by Cricbuzz.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.